Kendrick Lamar at the Grammys 2016. Image courtesy: AP
New York:
To belt, to dance, to rap or to mourn? The 58th annual Grammy Awards cycled through those modes on Monday night in its live broadcast from the Staples Center.
It's an awards show that has all but eliminated giving awards. Only eight competitive Grammys were announced on the three-and-half hour show; the other 75 awards were presented in an earlier webcast. The choices, slipped between nearly two dozen performances, continued the longtime stodginess of the Recording Academy, which presents the awards. The retro-style Meghan Trainor was best new artist, while the song of the year was Ed Sheeran's wedding-friendly love song
Thinking Out Loud. But the live performances drowned them out.
The Recording Academy was torn between the big voices and pretty faces of current hitmakers (and ratings magnets) like Taylor Swift, Justin Bieber and Adele (although her album,
25, isn't eligible until next year's Grammys) and coping with the deaths of generational heroes: David Bowie, BB King, Glenn Frey of the Eagles, Maurice White of Earth, Wind and Fire and Lemmy Kilmister of Motorhead.
The show was also atoning for the 2014 snub of Kendrick Lamar, who lost best rap album to Macklemore and Ryan Lewis at the time. Lamar's 2015 album
To Pimp a Butterfly swept this year's hip-hop categories, and he gave the show's central performance - although
To Pimp a Butterfly lost to Taylor Swift's
1989 as album of the year. (Swift and Lamar also shared a Grammy this year for the video of her single that features him,
Bad Blood.)
Kendrick Lamar's live segment drew on
The Blacker the Berry and
Alright from
To Pimp a Butterfly, with Lamar sidestepping their profanities; it also mentioned Feb. 26, 2012, the date Trayvon Martin was killed. The performance was a vehement, multilevel blast against "modern day slavery" that's bound for extensive Internet exegesis. It was staged with prisoners breaking chains and African-style drummers and dancers against a bonfire backdrop, ending with the name of Lamar's hometown, Compton, superimposed on a silhouette of Africa.
The other flagship Grammys performance was Lady Gaga's tribute to David Bowie. Orange-haired and seemingly changing a costume a minute, splashed with video effects, Lady Gaga raced through snippets of Bowie's hits, mixed a vocal impression of him with her own delivery and hit her marks with dance moves that echoed some of Bowie's. She got close to guitarist Nile Rodgers, the co-producer of
Let's Dance, who was prominent in the backup band.
With the Grammys on a Monday night, when Broadway is usually dark, the show was able to include a performance of the opening number of the historical hip-hop musical
Hamilton live from its Broadway Theater-and, soon afterward, a rapped acceptance speech by Lin-Manuel Miranda for Best Musical Theater album.
It's a worthy paradox that the academy's broadcast revolves around live - not recorded- music. And it's not the worst thing that the show can turn, at times, into a showcase for competitive belting. Some acts put current performers side by side, singing each others' hits-and revealing, probably unintentionally, how interchangeable they were.
A country pairing-Sam Hunt and Carrie Underwood-showed both singers drawing their phrasing not from old-style country, but from hip-hop and R&B; meanwhile, a tribute to Lionel Richie, capped by Richie himself, revealed how much country he brought into 1970s soul.
Andra Day and Ellie Goulding sang ballads with escalating melismas; James Bay and Tori Kelly, two best new artist nominees, traded their songs on acoustic guitars, ramping up the vibrato. Taylor Swift's opening number,
Out of the Woods, was an arena-scale stomp, delivered straight into the camera; Alabama Shakes, who dominated the rock categories, started
I Don't Wanna Fight with a shriek and kept that intensity all the way through.
The 2016 awards offered both the pleasures and pitfalls of live performance. Adele's full-tilt diva ballad,
All I Ask, was sabotaged early on by what sounded like a malfunctioning piano string, and Adele never quite recovered. Meanwhile, some Grammy-style genre-bending succeeded. Little Big Town's
Girl Crush shifted from 1950's rock to chamber music; The Weeknd's
In the Night survived as ballad. Justin Bieber - after strumming an acoustic guitar in
Love Yourself -switched the electronic dance music of
Where Are U Now to a hard-rock blowout, with Skrillex on electric guitar and Diplo pounding drums.
The tribute to B.B. King was
The Thrill Is Gone played by Bonnie Raitt, Chris Stapleton (the big country winner) and the Texas bluesman Gary Clark, Jr. with heartfelt blues fervor. Meanwhile, a segment by Hollywood Vampires - Alice Cooper, Johnny Depp and Joe Perry of Aerosmith - that was billed as a tribute to Motorhead started, crassly, with one of the Vampires' own songs. And
Take It Easy, sung by Jackson Browne with the surviving Eagles, just sounded weary.
Stevie Wonder was a paragon of musicality and awards show jujitsu. After he lifted Earth, Wind & Fire's
That's the Way of the World above Pentatonix's thicket of vocal beatboxing and a cappella harmonies, he called for universal accessibility for the disabled. Then he opened the envelope for song of the year and flaunted its Braille lettering before the camera, making the audience wait. "You can't read Braille, a nana na na na," he teased.
© 2015, The New York Times News Service
(This story has not been edited by NDTV staff and is auto-generated from a syndicated feed.)