»  SciDev Eye  »   Post
Will India find water on moon?
Tuesday August 25, 2009

The moon played host to a unique Indo-US tango, all done in a bid to confirm the existence of water on the otherwise parched moon.
 
It seems water is the true unifying force between two of the world's most respected space agencies. The American space agency NASA had recently warned about how India's granary Punjab and Haryana were being sucked dry due to over use of ground water. On its part the Indian Space Research Organization has also been keeping track of soil moisture over India in an effort to alleviate the misery caused because of the drought.
 
But finding water on the moon is a much tougher challenge. On the lunar North pole a unique `bi-static' experiment was conducted on August 20, in a bid to search for water ice.  The maiden Indian lunar craft Chandrayaan-1 and the American satellite Lunar Reconnaissance Orbiter that are both currently in the moon's orbit were  brought within 30 kilometers of each other and synchronously the onboard mini RADAR's of each was focused on the Erlanger crater, signals sent in tandem to this permanently shaded crater were picked up. 
 
Indian scientists point to a search for water ice above the moon's north pole, conducted with the United States on August 20, as a sign that India's lunar craft Chandrayaan-1 is functioning well. India's first lunar satellite had trouble earlier this year with a fine guidance mechanism. This tango was carried out at a distance of 400,000 kilometers from earth went on for a full 4 minutes when both spacecrafts were traveling at a velocity of 1.6 kilometers per second. Calling it 'a unique and complex experiment performed with precision' G. Madhavan Nair, Chairman, Indian Space Research Organization, Bangalore, said this 'duet' brings scientist closer to understanding the moon's composition. The data from this one of its kind experiment is still being analyzed.
 
So, are we today better placed to solve the mystery on the presence of water on the moon? 'I think so' says Paul D. Spudis, Principal Investigator for the RADAR instruments onboard both the spacecrafts who works at Lunar and Planetary Institute, Houston who feels 'multiple spacecraft looking at the lunar poles with multiple instruments and we will soon have an abundance of data on the problem. That doesn't mean we will solve it, but we will be much better informed than at any previous time.' Finding water is the key for future colonization of the moon.

 
   SocialTwist Tell-a-Friend
Comments: Read | Post
Comments Post your comments
 
Posted by Santanu on Aug 26, 2009
I agree that the basic primary needs like drinking water or water for irrigation is absolutely necessary and the govt setup/org responsible for ensuring that should be made accountable , rather than a scientific organization. We can not deny the importance of any one of the finger in a hand, although none of them are equal. Hope one does not have to lose one to learn its importance.
 
Posted by bzach on Aug 26, 2009
All those who are pessimistic about sending lunar satellite should remeber that we cannot wait till all the villages have water taps and wells before starting on research work on space exploration.I understand that we should be more serious about the problems we face in earth than going to moon but ISRO didnt happen yesterday and it takes years of research and teamwork before we even can put a satellite up in the orbit. If we hadnt put any satellite then we would be lacking in weather,defense and all other things that a developing nation should do to move forward. We didnt get our independence in a day or a year,similarly we should work towards removing poverty.It might take another twenty years to get rid of poverty but shoudnt that be our vision for our and our childrens future.Peace.
 
 
Posted by sasi on Aug 26, 2009
Agreed on all your thoughts. Now, tell me what are the ways to solve water/electricity poverty problems? let us not play blame game . Goverment is nothing but you and me. We talk about corrution but when I get a chance to take a bribe I never think. I am a plotician, an IAS officer, a police/tax comissioner/constable, a mine/well inspector, a stock broker, teacher, contractor... above all I am a common man! I am corrupt and indeferrent. I am a cheater and a liar! For millions of years I just lived for my self and I am still not satisfied! Where am I going? What is my goal? Is there a happy ending? If yes, where and when? If no, if it is only sad ending then why does it not end right now? A millioon questions but need just one answer.
 
Posted by Shadow on Aug 26, 2009
We have enough water on earth,lets connect rivers togeather,and reduce our emission levels. 1.Check the Automobile Emission Level 2.Check the Industrial Emission Level 3.Grow Trees 4.Improve Irrigation Rain will Follow.Insted of wasting money on finding water in moon.If there is water in moon,india's corupted Government Officials will sell moon,God save the moon.
 
Posted by SUNIL KUMAR on Aug 26, 2009
What are we going to do after finding water in the moon??? Connect a pipe to the moon and draw water from there to use it here???
 
Posted by avi on Aug 26, 2009
Couple of years ago I heard from a person that "India is not in a position to design a 100 CC motor bike and they are sending rockets to space". By the way I want to add one more line, we human want to reach Moon just to get Hilium III from there, which can be used as hi grade fuel, if I am not wrong.
 
Posted by Arjan Basu Roy on Aug 26, 2009
I am in Japan for the last four months, working on Butterflies. Just yesterday there was a farewell dinner for me as i am returning to my country very soon. At that dinner i praise all my Japanese friend and asked how you people are so polite, so generous, so helpful to each other? One of my friend Mr Oshumi replied because at this point of time we have enough food to eat and enough water to drink, so we are patient and tollerent, and showing all the good gestures to each other. If we dont have enough food and water in future, we may not be like what you are seeing now. In Japan where there is no shortage of technical advancement, resourse and all those things required for a experiment like Chandrayan 1, they are only focused in the well-being of there common people. To the government each Japanese life counts in a manner that we Indian couldn't think of. Every corner of Japan is now connected by Telephones, have electricity, metal road. And still every day they are trying to provide their people more ease for daily leaving. And remember Japan is a densely populated country unlike USA,Canada or Australia. My point is, yes proving yourself technically sound is fine but at what cost? At the cost of our very own fellow country man, at the cost of the education of our children, from the pain of a mother who feels bad for not feeding her children proper food? I will call this an absolute hypocracy. First you arrange things for the present, properly, so that our survival is ensured, then think for the colonization in moon!! Dear government, prove yourself efficient for your own countrymen first, then show what ever you want to show to the world, we have no objection. Connect all part of our country through electricity, telecommunication, health benefits, education and then show your authority on communication with your sattelite, 400000 km away from the earthen truth!!
 
Posted by P V SHRINIVASAN on Aug 25, 2009
After 63 years of independence there are thousands and thousands of citizens who are still struggling to meet their water needs. It would have been better for India to invest in tapping the water resources and work on the water conservation systems than to vouch for a mirage of water on the moon. The next world war would not be for oil or mines....it would be only for water and this would be a war only for the survival of the fighting soldiers...the country will be the second option.
 
Posted by seshan subramanian on Aug 25, 2009
I totally agree. India needs to spend more money on solving the problems of it spoor population. We have 39% of the populaiton living below poverty line. India shoudl not be spending money on psace research and other projects that do not benefit the general population. It is a false prestige to try to compete with the US and other nations who do not have millions of people living in pooveryt like India.
 
Posted by vasans on Aug 25, 2009
Indi has the power to re establish herself to be the powerful economy in the world. Natural disasters are inevitable and India is woking tremendously to fix all her problems.
 
Posted by nk verma on Aug 25, 2009
No. There is no chance of getting the water on the moon.
 
Posted by Ruchis Khatiwala on Aug 25, 2009
I agree with the comments by Cliff. Why cant we invest massively in irrigating the whole country so that Indian agriculture would not be dependent on just monsoons anymore? These investments and technological advances of finding water on moon are justifiable actions to secure the distant future (probably) but does it help ailing Indian people going through drought in near future?
 
Posted by VJ on Aug 25, 2009
Two of the worlds most respected space agencies, I get NASA but ISRO? Come on now. Also as Cliff Rosario said, we should first try to help people here on earth and in India who are starving and thirsty. India has always had lopsided ambitions that didnt match the reality on the ground.
 
Posted by Aseem Dixit, NY NY on Aug 25, 2009
Yes we are BLIND and STUPID and SELFISH and basically have a COULDNT CARELESS attitude. 62 yeard and more than 75000 villages do not know what electricity is, theyve heard of it but have not experienced it, they do not know what it feels to have water coming out of a faucet because theyve never seen a faucet, they do not know what it feels to see enough water in their wells, they do not know what it feels to have enough water for their farms, they do not what it feels to have their stomachs full and always have enough food to feed their families, they do not know that it thier right to live like a human even though theyre poor, they havent been told that its the duty of the govt to provide them with the basic neccessities in order to at least survive as human. ater 62 years the govt. in that country couldnt provide education to those seeking it, after 62 years the govt. couldnt provide jobs to those seeking them, after 62 years the govt. couldnt provide water for the farmers who feed the rest of the country, after 62 years the govt couldnt provide everybody with the bare minimum food clothing and shelter and after 62 years the govt. couldnt provide a single glass of water to villagers which is potable!!!! what in gods name are we doing looking for water on the moon. in a country like India where 38% of the country lives in extreme poverty and 77% of the total population lives in poverty , we need to provide the bare minimums like food water and electricity in order for people to survive and NOT go out and spend ridiculous amounts of monies with other countries to find water on the moon!!!!
 
Posted by Namrat Gaonkar on Aug 25, 2009
Despite 62 years of Independence people mostly women even now have to trek for miles together to fetch water for cleaning & drinking for the entire family. It would be prudent for a developing country to use its resources for the benefit of the people who still have to resort to primitive methods to eke out a decent living for themselves.What would we do if we find water on the moon?what purpose would it serve? The govt should use its resorces to tackle the menacing drought situation prevailing in the country & try to reduce the spiralling prices which is running close to a all time high.
 
Posted by Cliff Rosario on Aug 25, 2009
Our country should first spend money on finding water for the drought-hit states. While one state is affected by floods, another state is afflicted by drought and results in shortage of crops and farmer suicides. Are we all blind here or plain stupid?
 
 
Post Your Comments Fields marked with * are mandatory
*Name:
E-mail:
*Comments:
  Limit 4000 characters - 4000 characters remaining
*Secure Code:
  Problem viewing this image. Click to refresh
 
 
Kindly do not post any defamatory, infringing, obscene, indecent, discriminatory or unlawful material or information. NDTV Convergence Ltd reserves the right to remove without notice any content received from users.
 
Advertisement
Advertisement
On Facebook
About Me
Pallava Bagla, Science Editor of NDTV is a globally acclaimed science communicator. Winner of India's highest award for science journalism in 2005 and conferred the 'Outstanding Journalism' award by the United Nations in 2003. Author of several books, the latest being 'Destination Moon: India's Quest for Moon, Mars and Beyond' published by HarperCollins. His pioneering multi media campaign in making Chandrayaan-1, truly a people's mission got critical acclaim.
Latest Posts
The Untouchables: Bombay Police after 26/11
There is a story the officers of Bombay police like to tell: of brotherhood, risk and the fight against evil.
Ever-reddy
For the Reddys to be hailed as only the kings of Bellary, was galling. Their sights were set over controlling north Karnataka.
Tawang, in preparation
Tawang is in bridal makeup. Dressed for the occasion to receive their Spiritual Guru. It's a pretty picture of festivity.