»  Live from the Newsroom  »   Post
India vs Bharat
Monday April 20, 2009 , New Delhi

Have just returned from two weeks on the heat and dust of the campaign trail, a world away from air conditioned television debates, a divide as deep as the two worlds of India vs Bharat.

 

The fascinating and most challenging thing about Election 2009 for politicians and pollsters alike, is that there is no one overarching theme....it's a mish mash of a variety of issues, ranging from national leaders to the local candidate to even the pradhan who's taken a Rs 5,000 bribe before releasing funds for a pukka house.

 

Manifestoes do not figure here as candidates try to convince people living in huts, that this election will change their lives....for the voter in rural India, it is about why getting even a monthly widows pension of Rs 300 requires a bribe. The greatest villains here are the local pradhans, meant to be elected as the village's voice, instead they're the first to abandon them. In fact, one of the greatest resentments is that as soon as a villager is made a pradhan, his or hers first priority is to build a house, buy land and then concentrate on building up a power base to make sure he/she wins the next election. And  perhaps why the corruption in politics is now so widespread, is because it literally begins at the grassroots.

 

Also, for rural India, elections equal a different kind of empowerment. This is when the politicians come calling, when they are wooed with free dinners, cash handouts and every possible sop. Its a trap most voters fall into, no one thinks of the best candidate, but the one who can offer the most at that  moment...no wonder, colour TVs and free cycles are part of most regional parties' manifestoes. And eventually, it is the voters who will be victims for the next five years. Yet, the enthusiasm and energy of elections here is something we do not see in our cities..an energy that could be converted into so much good if only the right people are elected.  That perhaps should be what we focus on, that just as we the voters, have our rights, we also have a duty to make sure the best man or woman wins.   

 

HERO'INE' OF THE WEEK: Priyanka Gandhi, for effortlessly being India's most natural, unstarry politician, even though she confines herself to just one constituency

 

ZERO OF THE WEEK: The Samajwadi Party for its bizarre manifesto saying English and Computer studies should not be encouraged, in order to promote a level playing field !
 
   SocialTwist Tell-a-Friend
Comments: Read | Post
Tags: Bharat , India

Comments Post your comments
Showing 1-20 of 25
 
Posted by Sudhir Khanna on Jun 16, 2009
The time has come when this country can still take a different path. India vs Bharat will continue forever. Even in western countries we have the rural/urban divide. In any socio-politic entity there should always be a balance - nothing should go to extremes. If there are even 1% of Indians who want to make this country a little better than it is right now ( in fact maintaining status quo itself is a great challenge ), then they need to dedicate a part of their lives towards bringing about change. As they say "if you can't beat em, join em". Join politics, join the Administrative services, join the police and armed forces, become village chiefs. Infiltrate all possible sources of corruption and mismanagement. For a while you have to flow according to the river, and when you feel that your voice can be heard, then you should bring about the change you require. But the biggest challenge is that this revolution should start from the rural heart of india where most of the populace is. We need to find new converts to this thought process. This is a chance for the youth of our country to re-build this nation. The best part is that they need not shed any blood like the freedom fighters, all they need to do is to spread their thoughts to the people. These youths will not be able to do it without any power in hand. They will have to acquire power ( probably using the wrong means for the time being ) and then once they are in a position where they can command/convince/convert people, they should do so. They can then represent the masses of india, who are so innocent that they do not know what is right or what is wrong. All they know is that they have their own and other stomachs to feed in their family. The numbers of the corrupt are increasing day by day. These numbers need to be reduced. Corruption needs to be fought with. If somebody has to pay a bribe to receive a pension of even 300 rs then it is a shame that we are part of this nation. We can declare that we have to fight corruption and that we should stop bribing. But is it practically possible. When even the basic necessities of life have to be taken care of by bribing, then it is difficult to survive without bribing. We have to cleanse the system of corruption. All of these words are very easy to write on paper, but doing it practically is the challenge. Do the youth of our country have the drive and the inclination to take these risks. If yes, then nobody can stop this nation becoming the leader in the modern day world. We have everything with us, Natural resources, strategic importance, science and technology, softskills, engineering excellence, vast pool of english speaking people. An average child in India has more IQ and analytical skills than an average child in the western world. We have everything but we lack the WILL TO DO SOMETHING DIFFERENT. The youth of our country are looking for an easy life, most of them are searching for easy ways to lead a better life for themselves. This is the root of corruption. This is what needs to be changed. CHANGE IS GOOD BUT WILL IT HAPPEN?????????
 
Posted by SRINIVASA RAO J. on May 19, 2009
Dr.ManMohanSingh couldnot do much in the past term, as he was continuously being leg pulled by the left. Now that UPA is devoid of left, Dr MMS will gear up to show his strength in economic progress; stock market rise on the day of election result is an ample evidence of how the public reacted to this.
 
 
Posted by Sushant Srivastav on May 06, 2009
UPA is urgent power arrangement. There is nothing progressive only retrograde and renegades enjoyed the benefits of power. Is there any progress any where tell me. Only the power mongers progressed. SRP family, lallu family, Mulayam family, Paswan family, Karunanidhi family progressed. MMS slept thougout the 5 years in the PM chair. He realised 5 years are over only yesterday. He is making some noise now a days after snoring loudly for 5 years.
 
Posted by vasudevan on Apr 30, 2009
One issue is handling of terrorism When we talk about Mumbai attack the congress say what about Kandahar? Are they similar? At Kandahar Terrorist were at foreign soil Hostages at foreign soil Security forces were foreign The govt was trying to save the lives of innocent hostages BUT in MUMBAI Terrorist in India Hostages in India Security forces in India Over 200 people got killed Did the UPA handled it better?
 
Posted by rajiv on Apr 28, 2009
Biggest similarity in secular brigade is they destroyed the economy of his own state and now masses from these state(UP, Bihar , West Bengal etc.) going to better ruled state like Gujrat and Maharastra , Karnatka.etc. Lalu Mulayam , Left secularism means (Secularism = Destruction and poverty.) Why not some one ask question to Lalu, Mulayam and left , they ruled UP and Bihar and Bengal for several years and people from these state are poorest on the earth. They do not have answer to question how job will be created in there respective state. Then only talk about Teacher appointment and constable appointment on the name of job creation. Still these people are able to grab power then we need to punish people who elects them again and again. Muktar Ansari , Rabari Devi and Sahabuddin voter's does not deserve to get Job any where. Once they will have threat on there livelihood then they will understand why we need good leaders to rule the country. We have issue with this Lalu and Mulayam brand of Secularism , They only talk about secularism and sent Bihar into 16th century, Bihar can not afford Rabri to be CM again. If M-Y vote for them , then we have issue with Muslims , we will appeal to all in India, please block these people coming out of these states and do not hire supporter of destroyer in any job. Other wise they will destroy your company or workplace too. Not every one from these state is bad . World highest paid executive in Bihari ( Sanjay Jha Motorola CEO).
 
Posted by Sudhir on Apr 23, 2009
Modiji is the answer!!!!!! Vande Matram!
 
Posted by K.Ragavan. on Apr 23, 2009
Interesting and meaningful article.Ihave been watching Indian Politics for the Past Four and half decades,no improvement in the Politicians speech,during election time.Same speeches and un imaginable promises.Whoever come to power no body is going to take care of the common man's problem.Corruption will continue from bottom to top further.Unless and untill politicians will have consciousness then only we can see a Ram rajya.With all MultipartySystem,fighting,and violence India is thriving because of our Ancient culture and Ancestors blessings.We have to choose which thief is better.All are same.Ipray for calm peaceful life for a ordinary citizen. Jai hind. K.Ragavan.
 
Posted by Kris on Apr 23, 2009
Calling Priyanka Gandhi "Heroine of the Week" is ridiculous.She is confined to only Two Seats out of 540 odd seats even then entire media jamboree is behind her for sound bytes about various topics which are unrelated to those constituencies.This shows even a supposed to be responsible,secular & unbiased media company like NDTV has fallen for the trap and is showing Sycophancy towards Congress and especially to Gandhi family More than canvassing for those seats which in any case are meant for Congress she should concentrate more on the development of those economically backward constituencies after elections
 
Posted by troodost on Apr 23, 2009
The choice today as always is between the rich - who has all And the poor who struggles for days roti...middlesclass - the largest in the world - cares only for self...
 
Posted by Ravi Shankar on Apr 23, 2009
I think we all need to understand the reality before blaming the poor and illiterate people who vote for money .yes they don't think about candidate and why should they. If I was poor ,even I would have done the same ,one vote one TV good deal I will sell it and buy same food .there present is bad how can we expect them to see the future . One who should be blamed is our constitution which allows this type of candidate to fight election and all literate people who don't vote which includes me. Instead of worrying about corruption at bottom we should be worried about top level corruption
 
Posted by Abijita Debata on Apr 22, 2009
I am following the India-election from Dallas, USA...so may be I don't have a full picture of the situation. but looking around ( see our neighbors) I still think we have a good democracy...no one party can rule (coalition), leadership changes when people are unhappy with the performance ( BJP was kicked out) and though urban and rural areas are not growing at the same pace everytime I go to our village in orissa, i see atleast 2 more families in better economic condition than the last time. Bribe and corruption are the main issue according to me. but that can be handled ONLY by the people.if there is a combined effort by the general masses bribery and corruption will reduce drastically. About Priyanka Gandhi, I don't disagree that she is doing her duites in her constituency (her father - in-law dying is noway related to judge her as a politician).
 
Posted by Debasish Sengupta on Apr 22, 2009
Not only the current one, but the earlier elections too had shown how the leaders of different political parties had continuously tried to make fool of us, the general people of India. We are habituated with this and don't expect any major or minor changes in the life after any of the elections. Be it a cabinet minister or a pradhan, most of them are focussed on making their life better at the cost of people's. The entire political and social structure is rotten and we can't expect anything better. It asks for a social revolution at the grass root level under a true leadership to change the present scenario. None of the existing leaders is having that leadership capability as most of them are at the deadend of their lives and are unable to dream. You need to be young in health and mind for dreaming of a better future for yourself as well as the coming generations.
 
Posted by Siddarth Jogia on Apr 22, 2009
The choice today is between Dangaa (Riots) versus Development (Peace & Progress). Vote for BJP is a vote for Dangaa. Vote for Congress a vote for Development. The people are the masters %u2013 and they will choose what they want. Dangaa or Development. The only point I want to stress is that the voter of India must make an informed choice.
 
Posted by Arun srivastava on Apr 21, 2009
No use cribbing.The only solution lies in National Government- best economists,technocrats,bureaucrats etc picked up from the nominees or winners of national awards,and headed by the best retired general from the armed forces.Rubbish should be dumped once for all.Needs amending the constitution for giving just one chance unless asked to repeat,through referendum.
 
Posted by Deshal Shah on Apr 21, 2009
There is a lot of groundwork required in terms of election manifestos and the way the leaders are appeasing people ---particularly the minorities and lower strata. Our politicians have become the perfect example of displaying how the system can be flouted and played around. They have literally turned into power hungry and money hungry individuals. It is the fact that today you would never come across a poor politician. So much is the money in the business of politics that people resort all kinds of means and ends to gain candidature for standing in the elections. It is a sorry state of affairs where in nobody wants to serve people but serve their own pockets and power hunger.
 
Posted by Pradeep Baisakh on Apr 21, 2009
When I was a child, I used hear during election that so and so candidate was heavily pooled in favour by the people becasue he districuted money to them just on eve of elections. Time has not changed even after 20-25 odd years.There are for sure no easy solutions to this problem, and unfortunately, this trend of distributing money on eve of the pools to win voters is to continue for time to come, nobody exactly can say when it would stop. I call myself as a people's journalsit as I like writing the plight of people on grassroots. I have raomed around rural areas of Orissa and also some in Jharkhand, I find one real reason for corruption at the local levels. It is the money power in elections. I am of the view that to a good extent this trend will come down If we go for a state funing of elctions. A lot of money will go from public exchequre, but imagine the benifits that will be acrued to in terms of freeing the elections from the clutches of criminals and from the influence of money and muscle power. I see in implementation of schemes like NREGS , the activists who are exposing corruption by way of conducting social audits, are being beaten or killed by the vested interest goups which constitute the local contractor-bureaucracy and politicians.And this chain is linked to upper level of bureaucracy and politicians. The PC culture, where a fixed percentage of welfare related expenses goes to the implemntors and then channelised to the high ups, is a great menace and has to be stopped. debarring private funding of elections may help in this.
 
Posted by Badrinarayanan Srinivasan on Apr 21, 2009
"HERO'INE' OF THE WEEK: Priyanka Gandhi, for effortlessly being India's most natural, unstarry politician, even though she confines herself to just one constituency" Yep she was so much busy that they found the heroine's father-in-law hanging in his apartment without anybody nearby. A pathetic suicide. Before serving the constituency of Amethi by Showing OFF her "assets" in support of her Brother, Heroine should have taken care of house and father-in-law maybe? Socho Hindustan Socho. I bet if this comment will be shown in this "secular" website.
 
Posted by Narayan on Apr 21, 2009
I would like to say that while 'India' is nothing but just a beautiful and glitzy wallpaper/screensaver to attract the attention of the westerners, 'Bharat' showcases the stark reality of squalor. 'India' has people moving around in swanky airconditioned cars, stylish sunglasses and expensive accessories. 'Bharat' has people struggling to make ends barely meet; work in their agricultural fields with their sweat and grime; ultimately fighting a rather losing battle to 'India' land-sharks who pay them a pittance and land sharks sell the land at double rates. If this trend continues, we all will have nothing to eat, even if you have money in your pocket! Why, because no agricultural land available to grow crops. Wake up, people, and save our Bharat, identify yourself as Bharatiyas, NOT as Indians!
 
Posted by White head on Apr 20, 2009
Kudos to Sonia Singh for bringing out the first ever fine-print X-ray photo of "ailing rural India".Bapu said "India lives in its innumerable villages!."As long as the roots of"true Democracy" do not spread in that soil, the reprehensible edifice of pseud democracy will continue.it is, however, hjoped that the general elections of 2009, will prove to be a "watershed in the history of Indian Elections.Since 54 crores out of 71 crore voters are in the age group 18 - 35 and having good awareness of facts of Indian life,may not rush to press the button (in the EVM)for the"symbol of the party they like most;, as in the past elections.They will deem it a sin to press the button for candidate with CRIMINAL RECORD and thus cut the very root of Muscle power in politics! Next they will not even turn in the direction of corrupt,sycophantic and divisivepoliticans cutting the roots of India's unity and integrity!real democracy will be ocupying the driver's now, as never before!Once the results are announced many will join the swelling crowd of "castaways" leaders and candidates! Young India will choose its representatives who have the qualities of head and heart to map out their fears and aspirations and fill their "felt needs!"They want men of vision and futuristic orientation to enable the youth to successfully strive and surpass the rivals in an emerging world of "acute competitions" in the 2010s! By 2015, India is sure to become the number one nation with the largest population in the world, hence the MP selected now should visualize the needs and problems of people in India in 2014 and be in a position to tackle them with ease.Hence, the voters now have to bear great responsibility and get rid of shackles of "loyalty' to the party and ideology' and the thoughts of "genuine Indianism" to save the unity, integrity and development of India and Indians , must permeate their entie being.
 
Posted by Linc. on Apr 20, 2009
**Yet, the enthusiasm and energy of elections here is something we do not see in our cities..an energy that could be converted into so much good if only the right people are elected. That perhaps should be what we focus on, that just as we the voters, have our rights, we also have a duty to make sure the best man or woman wins.** If all players in a constituency are goonda's, corrupt..(which i think nearly all are) what do I do..?? Enjoy the holiday and the 'intense' discussions news channels show.. :D **ZERO OF THE WEEK: The Samajwadi Party for its bizarre manifesto saying English and Computer studies should not be encouraged, in order to promote a level playing field!!** This doesn't even bring a smile to my face.. the greediness..hunger for power.. means..i totaly cringe and get goose bumps when i imagine that actually happening.. (n yea the same with mayawati as the PM,even her projection as PM candidate).. Yesterday only i realized corruption can most probably never be eradicated from India as parties survive on that.. If there weren't business houses..supplying money.. then how would sonia gandhi or advani eat.. :O.. they don't do any work .. or don't have any business.. Before him becoming PM i knew little of manmohan singh.. but had respect for him.. n now he too has been dragged by left n all others to play politics.. Nothings gonna stop these things.. just people lighting candles or doing marches wont do anything..If you think.. somethings happening (cause of the katara case n all..) well then there are 100's of cases like dat every year.. Laato ke bhoot.. baato se nai maan te.. our politicians just arent ghosts.. they are evil.. just pure evil.. **I might not get everything..but thats what u'd get from a youngster..who follows things.. otherwise most even don't.. your channel only showed that some weeks ago..**
 
 
Post Your Comments Fields marked with * are mandatory
*Name:
E-mail:
*Comments:
  Limit 4000 characters - 4000 characters remaining
*Secure Code:
  Problem viewing this image. Click to refresh
 
 
Kindly do not post any defamatory, infringing, obscene, indecent, discriminatory or unlawful material or information. NDTV Convergence Ltd reserves the right to remove without notice any content received from users.
 
Advertisement
Advertisement
On Facebook
About Me
Sonia Singh is the Managing Editor, NDTV 24x7.
Latest Posts
The Untouchables: Bombay Police after 26/11
There is a story the officers of Bombay police like to tell: of brotherhood, risk and the fight against evil.
Ever-reddy
For the Reddys to be hailed as only the kings of Bellary, was galling. Their sights were set over controlling north Karnataka.
Tawang, in preparation
Tawang is in bridal makeup. Dressed for the occasion to receive their Spiritual Guru. It's a pretty picture of festivity.