» Story
 
  SocialTwist Tell-a-Friend
Goa MP suggests Russian rape victim asked for it
NDTV Correspondent, Tuesday December 15, 2009, Panaji, Goa

A Congress MP from Goa has caused a storm in Parliament by suggesting that women who are raped by men they socialize with are at least partly responsible for what happens to them.

The MP was referring to the controversial case of a Russian woman working in Goa who claims she was raped earlier this month by a South Goa politician in his car after having dinner with him.

Shantaram Naik said while rape is a  heinous crime, "...an alleged rape of a lady who moves with strangers for days together even beyond middle of the night is to be treated on different footings."

Naik's comments evoked strong protests by opposition members particularly Brinda Karat (CPM), Najma Heptulla, Maya Singh (BJP)and Jaya Bachchan (SP).

They sought intervention of the Deputy Chairman K Rahman Khan saying Naik should not be allowed to speak the language which, they said, was derogatory to women.

The Russian who was allegedly raped was working at a five-star hotel in Goa. She says that on the first of December, a friend and she had dinner with  South Goa politician, John Fernandes, who allegedly spiked her drink and then raped her in his  car.

The police claimed it couldn't find Fernandes and therefore couldn't arrest him; NDTV, however, had no trouble tracking down the politician who discussed  the allegations against him at length in an interview.

On Monday, a court cancelled the anticipatory bail granted earlier to Fernandes.

The case seems to be the latest example of lax investigations by the Goa Police. For one, the police seemed reluctant to medically exam the victim for evidence of rape; it also did not search Fernandes' car, the alleged scene of the crime, for several days.

The alleged victim has complained officially to the Russian Consulate that she has been pressured repeatedly by the police to drop the case, and that she feels unsafe.

Last week, the Goa Tourism Minister, Fransisco Pacheco, in a letter to the state's chief minister,  has complained that this and other cases like the rape and murder of British teenager Scarlett Keeling are damaging the reputation of Goa. Pachecho wrote, the police in Goa is either "grossly incompetent or influenced by other factors", as a result of which complaints were not properly investigated.

In the Keeling case, little evidence  was presented by the police against the Goa shack-owner accused of raping and murdering the teenager last year. The investigation is now being handled by the CBI.
SocialTwist Tell-a-Friend     
Comments: Read | Post
Comments
Posted by Equality on Dec 18, 2009
This is what one gets, when he speaks the truth. The Goa MP, spoke the truth, and the media has bashed the poor guy. Some immoral girls get into relationship with men, to gain some benefits. And when the relationship turns sour, they cry rape.
Posted by mahesh on Dec 16, 2009
scenario1) I carry 500rs notes in open view showing it to all. some guy comes and shows me a gun and i start crying loudly - i need respect and police protection and anyone who suggests elsewise is a stupid fool etc scenario2) everytime other boys dont play wit me, i go to outside of village and shout lion, lion. after 2-3 times noone believes me. Misuse of laws like 498a, rape is pushing indian women there; now foreigners also jumping in the bandwagon...
Advertisement
Advertisement
On Facebook