The cheese board had arrived but her entree had not when Sanders was asked to get up from her table and, kindly, leave.
Sanders tweeted as much over the weekend, saying she was given the boot "because I work for @POTUS," referring to President Donald Trump. The owner of the restaurant - which is about 190 miles from the White House - told The Post that to uphold her business's standards of honesty and compassion, Sanders had to go.
But for Twitter users, angry callers and Yelp reviewers, geography be damned. Any restaurant bearing the name "Red Hen" with some kind of bird silhouette for a logo was lumped in with the one that showed Sanders the door.
Let's start a little closer to the White House, with the Red Hen in Washington. It's a charming little upscale neighborhood restaurant. Same name. Also has a logo of a hen. Did not host the White House press secretary.
It tried to make that clear: On Saturday, that Red Hen tweeted that Sanders "went to the unaffiliated [Red Hen in Lexington] last night, not to our DC-based restaurant."
That tweet received 4,400 replies from nonbelievers and supporters alike. To talk the naysayers down, the Red Hen responded to Twitter threads with the definition of "unaffiliated," sarcastic gifs and a reminder that businesses in the District of Columbia are prohibited from discriminating against people based on political views because they are in a federal district.
Then, Yelp. One user asked whether the Red Hen in Washington sells wine by the glass. Another wanted to know: "Is this restaurant related to the one in Lexington that denied service to Sarah Sanders? If so will stop by."
One reviewer wrote, "Hey, torch bearing internet mob, THIS IS NOT THAT RED HEN. Y'all out of towners need a lesson in basic geography."
Another took a more diplomatic approach: "Why not stop by anyway and show your support for this establishment that is being mistaken for the one in VA."
Alas, its owners might have welcomed the support. Instead the place was not only pulled into a social media storm but also - in a not so subtle protest - egged.
Turns out Red Hen restaurants are popping up all over. To the north, another Red Hen restaurant in Swedesboro, New Jersey, was lambasted for denying service to someone who never ate there.
Last night I was told by the owner of Red Hen in Lexington, VA to leave because I work for @POTUS and I politely left. Her actions say far more about her than about me. I always do my best to treat people, including those I disagree with, respectfully and will continue to do so— Sarah Sanders (@PressSec) June 23, 2018
According to NJ.com, angry phone calls and Facebook posts poured in on Saturday morning as the staff was getting ready for a private event. In a Facebook post that day, the Red Hen in Swedesboro wrote that it is an independent, family-owned business that happens to share the same name as the one in Virginia.
"Kindly check your facts before you erroneously defame an innocent business on Facebook," the post reads.
Next up: the Red Hen restaurant in Old Saybrook, Connecticut. Like Virginia, Connecticut was one of the original 13 colonies. But it is different from Virginia.
Now, before visitors can access that Red Hen's website, a message pops up saying the eatery has "absolutely no affiliation with any other Red Hen restaurant anywhere else."
Especially that one.
Shelley Deproto, the owner of the Old Saybrook restaurant, told TheDay.com that 50 phone messages came in by noon on Saturday, including this ominous warning: "we're going to get you." Calls streamed in from across the country on Saturday once every minute, and continued into Sunday.
The restaurant's Yelp rating dropped from a 4.5 (of 5) before Friday night to a 2, Deproto told The Day. Some people placed fake take-out orders and said the restaurant cooked old meat.
"This is our livelihood," Deproto told The Day. "People here depend on this restaurant."
On Monday morning, President Donald Trump weighed in, saying the Red Hen should "focus more on cleaning its filthy canopies, doors and windows (badly needs a paint job)."
He did not specify which Red Hen.
(Except for the headline, this story has not been edited by NDTV staff and is published from a syndicated feed.)