This Article is From Sep 26, 2018

"Better To Be Unique Than Best": Top Court Upholds Aadhaar, With Limits

Aadhaar Verdict: The Supreme Court gave its verdict on 27 petitions that challenged the constitutional validity of the Aadhaar card.

Aadhaar Verdict: The Supreme Court said "very, very minimal data" is collected for Aadhaar.


  • "Private firms cannot insist on Aadhaar data," said Supreme Court
  • Aadhaar, however, has to be linked to citizens' PAN cards
  • "Aadhaar gives dignity to marginalised sections," said Supreme Court
New Delhi: The Aadhaar card empowers those on the margins of society, which far outweighs its flaws, the Supreme Court said today, upholding the validity of the giant national ID scheme but with limits on how biometric data collected from more than one billion citizens can be used. In a four-one majority judgement, the court cleared the use of Aadhaar for access to welfare schemes but struck down attempts to make it mandatory for bank accounts, mobile phone connections and school admissions.

Here are the top 10 updates on the Aadhaar verdict:

  1. Private companies cannot demand Aadhaar data linked to an individual's face, fingerprints and iris scans for access to their services, the court said in a 1,448-page verdict. But the 12-digit Aadhaar number has to be linked to citizens' PAN (Permanent Account Number) information for the filing of tax returns, the court ruled.

  2. The court also said Aadhaar is not compulsory for school admissions, for the Central Board of Secondary Education, the University Grants Commission and medical entrance test NEET. "No child shall be denied benefits for the want of Aadhaar," the judges said.

  3. The bench headed by Chief Justice Dipak Misra held that Aadhaar would be voluntary, with an option to exit. "Minimal demographic and biometric data of citizens are collected by UIDAI for Aadhaar enrolment and the system is serving much bigger public interest... We are of the view that there are sufficient safeguard to protect data collected under Aadhaar scheme," it said. 

  4. For the exclusion of a "minimal" three per cent, 97 per cent cannot be denied the benefits of Aadhaar, the top court, commenting: "One can't throw the baby out with the bathwater."

  5. No person will be denied benefits under the social welfare scheme because their Aadhaar card cannot be authenticated. But the court also directed the government not to give Aadhaar to illegal immigrants. "As of today, we do not find anything in Aadhaar Act which violates right to privacy of individual citizen," said the court in its verdict on 27 petitions that had challenged the merits of Aadhaar.

  6. "Aadhaar means unique and it is better to be unique than being best. Uniqueness is the fundamental difference between Aadhaar and other identity proofs. Aadhaar cannot be duplicated and it is a unique identification," the judges said.

  7. Justice DY Chandrachud's dissenting judgement held that Aadhaar is not constitutional and passing the Aadhaar law as money bill, thus bypassing the Rajya Sabha, was a "fraud on the Constitution".

  8. The scheme was rolled out under the previous Congress-led government in 2010. It began as a system to provide access to welfare schemes efficiently, but soon evolved into a mandatory ID for access to services like bank accounts, PAN cards, cellphone services, passport and even driving licenses.

  9. Last year, in a case linked to the biometric database, the government went to the Supreme Court to argue that Indians did not have a fundamental right to privacy. It lost the case. The court ruled that the right to privacy was an "intrinsic part of life and personal liberty", which is guaranteed by Article 21 of the Constitution.

  10. In what became the second longest case with hearings over 38 days, the Centre defended Aadhaar on several grounds - the biggest being that it ensured proper distribution of benefits to millions and prevented siphoning of funds.