- "Tubelight is unlikely to do quite as well," according to Taran Adarsh
- "#Tubelight rests on a thin plot," Mr Adarsh tweeted
- "Screenplay lacks the power to enthral and mesmerize," Mr Adarsh tweeted
"#Tubelight rests on a thin plot... Screenplay lacks the power to enthral and mesmerise... Emotions plenty, but few moments stand out..." he wrote on Twitter.
Adarsh added that it would still have an "awesome" weekend at the box office due to Monday's holiday and Khan's star power, but doubted it would eventually make three billion rupees ($46 million) internationally, the benchmark for a major hit.
#Tubelight rests on a thin plot... Screenplay lacks the power to enthral and mesmerise... Emotions plenty, but few moments stand out...— taran adarsh (@taran_adarsh) June 23, 2017
#Tubelight will have an awesome weekend extended weekend [Eid festivities]... Will it touch 300 cr, 400 cr, 500 cr? I doubt!— taran adarsh (@taran_adarsh) June 23, 2017
Tubelight, an adaptation of 2015 American movie Little Boy, is Khan's fourth straight Eid release and his seventh since 2010.
"For audiences Salman Khan is synonymous with Eid and for distributors Eid is synonymous with Salman Khan," trade analyst Akshaye Rathi told AFP.
Khan -- never far from controversy -- enjoys a cult-like status in star-obsessed India, particularly among young men who regularly stand outside his house in Mumbai hoping to catch a glimpse of the superstar.
He sparked uproar shortly before Sultan hit screens by saying his heavy training schedule for the film, in which he played an ageing wrestler, left him feeling "like a raped woman". The movie made around 5.8 billion rupees globally.
In 2015 Khan was cleared of killing a homeless man in a hit-and-run more than a decade earlier. That decision is now being challenged in the Supreme Court.
Indian authorities are also challenging a court's decision to acquit him over the illegal use of firearms to kill endangered antelopes in 1998.
(Except for the headline, this story has not been edited by NDTV staff and is published from a syndicated feed.)