This Article is From May 24, 2022

"Shameless Hypocrisy": Tamil Nadu Minister Challenges Nirmala Sitharaman

Tamil Nadu Finance Minister Palanivel Thiagarajan's fiery takedown came two days after Nirmala Sitharaman announced a series of tax cuts on fuel.

Tamil Nadu Finance Minister Palanivel Thiagarajan hit out Nirmala Sitharaman on Monday.

New Delhi:

Tamil Nadu Finance Minister Palanivel Thiagarajan pulled no punches as he took on Union Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman on Monday for "exhorting" states to cut their share of taxes on petrol and diesel, saying his state did not need "dictation from people who perform worse than us".

"We have one of the best statistical outcomes of any government in India. We brought the revenue deficit down from Rs 60,000 something to close to Rs 40,000 something crores. Our fiscal deficit is half that of the Union Government. Our per capita income is twice that of the national average. Our inflation is only 5 per cent when the national inflation is 8 per cent. We know what we are doing. We don't need anybody to tell us what to do. We don't need dictation from people who perform worse than us. We don't like other people extra-constitutionally, authoritarianly force us to do things we don't want to do," Mr Thiagarajan told NDTV in an interview.

"I don't recall them using anywhere the word 'request'. They gave demands and then I think the Union Finance Minister used the word 'exhort'. I don't think the constitution allows any of this to happen. The constitution allows states to manage their own finances to whatever extent we have left," he said.

"When the Union Government raised excise and that too shifted it from pure excise to cess and surcharge, three times on petrol and 10 times on diesel, they did not even consult the states. They cut the share given to us. At that time, they had no compassion, no consideration. They have had bad tax policy for seven-eight years, now that the chickens are coming home to roost, they are making fake villains out of us. This is atrocious. This is shameless hypocrisy," the minister said.

"It went up from Rs 9.4 to Rs 32.5, they cut Rs 5 once and Rs 8 once. You take away Rs 13, that's still Rs 19. That's still double the rate that was being taxed when this government came to power. Let's take diesel. It was Rs 3.4 or something, they took it up to Rs 32, they cut it by Rs 10 and another Rs 8 or 6 whatever they've cut. So, they are still four or five times where they were," Mr Thiagarajan added.

The DMK leader's fiery takedown came two days after Ms Sitharaman announced a series of tax cuts on fuel and changes to the levies on crucial commodities in a bid to insulate consumers from rising prices amid high inflation. She also asked states to chip in and reduce their share.

The new tax regime on petrol and diesel could result in a loss of about 1 trillion Indian rupees to the government in annual revenue due to the lower collection, she said in a series of tweets.