Rahul Gandhi Makeover Shows Expertise Beyond Prashant Kishor

Published: December 14, 2017 17:12 IST
The Gujarat election has ended and not a moment too soon. Both the BJP and Congress held nothing back in their campaigns. I want to leave the morality of their methods and rhetoric to one side and concentrate on the purely tactical aspects of the campaign.

The BJP always sensed it was in for a tough contest in Gujarat with local discontent boiling up in the last couple of years whether it arose from the Patidars, Dalits or farmers, and it eventually necessitated a change of Chief Minister but Vijay Rupani has proved to be a non-entity in this election. In fact, had either party thrown up a strong chief ministerial candidate, it could well have turned the election decisively in their favour, but during the dozen years of Modi-raj, he cast a shadow so large over Gujarat's polity that it stunted any chance of such a leader rising in either his own party or that of the opposition. For good or bad, this election was always destined to be the Modi Show it has turned out to be.

The Congress started slow in its usually lumbering fashion, losing early on a veteran leader like Shankersinh Vaghela and his supporters, but Ahmed Patel's last-minute win in the Rajya Sabha election in August seemed to rejuvenate the party that otherwise seemed set to be picked apart by Amit Shah's machinations. And then they managed to do the seemingly impossible feat of sewing together an alliance with the three musketeers: Hardik Patel, Jignesh Mevani, and Alpesh Thakor that provided the Congress a strong, if somewhat contradictory, caste equation as well the energy and enthusiasm that only youth can provide to a campaign. The BJP in return threw everything they had against these three young leaders of the future and their organizations, but they have stood strong throughout, especially Hardik Patel who has seemed to gather strength, confidence and ever larger crowds during the course of the campaign. Rahul Gandhi campaigned extensively as well during this early phase of the campaign, but he directed his attention mainly to economic issues and visiting every temple in sight, while trying his best to stay out of the way of his three young generals who took the lead in the ground battle against BJP across Gujarat. He largely succeeded, apart from the incident at Somnath Temple, though that controversy ultimately betrayed  the BJP's nervousness more than anything.
rahul gandhi somnath temple twitter 650

Congress vice-president Rahul Gandhi at the Somnath Temple in Gujarat

Then we awaited the arrival of our reigning political heavyweight, the Prime Minister, in the electoral fray, and after earning his requisite frequent flier miles of foreign travel, he took over the campaign and has basically done nothing else for the last month. Initially, he did try to concentrate on touting his "Gujarat Model" and vikas in his speeches, but he must have sensed the response from rallies was tepid with some reports of thin crowds. GST and note-bandi had clearly taken a toll even in Gujarat, and the BJP internal polls must have confirmed that reality. Thus, faced with weak economic ground realities, the Prime Minister's rhetoric turned to his old formula of personal attacks, religion-based appeals and bizarre accusations that share all the characteristics of bad political fiction. Mani Shankar Aiyar's 'neech' comment came as a gift for the PM and he made full use of it - nobody plays the part of the hurt and insulted son of the soil better. But then the PM's exuberance got the better of him when he accused Dr Manmohan Singh of treason for attending the now infamous dinner in honour of former Pakistani Foreign Minister KM Kasuri at that great man Mani Shankar Aiyar's residence. Shri Modi's totally baseless allegations may have worked, electorally speaking, had he directed them towards just about any other Congressman, but attacking Dr Manmohan Singh, a child of the partition and still considered the epitome of decency in our rapidly declining public life, was a big mistake, and even the most loyal of the PM's media admirers showed a newfound reluctance to follow him down this particular rabbit-hole. In perfectly-timed and succinct interventions over the last two days Dr Singh, hit back against the PM and reminded the nation that he can play the hurt victim card with almost the same expertise as his successor.

While all this campaign chaos was ensuing on the air waves, a most extraordinary metamorphosis was taking place in Rahul Gandhi. Gone was the uncertain, fidgety scion of the past decade; in his place was a leader who spoke in tones of calm reassurance with a slower cadence. Even his face seemed becalmed, but most important of all, he refused to take the BJP or the PM's bait with personal attacks. After swiftly suspending Aiyar from the party, an action that momentarily wrong-footed the BJP, he proclaimed he would never condone personal attacks against the Prime Minister and would concentrate his attention on talking about the issues of concern to Gujarat voters, but shrewdly remarked that the PM seemed to talk about everything under the sun except these same issues concerning Gujarat's development. This was a Rahul Gandhi who had found his voice; his speeches were on point. Even the anecdotes he told were polished and expertly recited, like in one of yesterday's banned interviews when he spoke of a pujari who gave a shawl to him for Sonia Gandhi. Such an effective transformation by a political leader in such a short period is not something that happens organically. I strongly suspect there is an extremely professional and experienced hand guiding Rahul behind the scenes, someone of a higher calibre than old favourite Prashant Kishor. This metamorphosis began during Rahul's tour of the United States and I would wager that this makeover expert is from there as well, someone with experience in moulding a US presidential candidate, perhaps someone from Sam Pitroda's hometown of Chicago. But that is pure conjecture and I'm sure the media will dig out the truth behind Rahul's new avatar sooner or later.
narendra modi gujarat 650

Prime Minister Narendra Modi at a rally in Lunawada in Mehsana district, Gujarat

In any other state election, you could have reasonably surmised by now that the ruling party is on the ropes and all signs point to its re-election prospects being dim, but the state in question is Gujarat, and the PM shares a bond with the voters of his state that is still very strong. They may want to bring him down a peg or two, but I'm not convinced they want to hobble his premiership, which would be the case if the  BJP is defeated because a Congress government is likely to inquire into every nook and cranny of Modi's long tenure as Chief Minister.

This could explain the PM's over-the-top rhetoric in recent days: if he loses Gujarat, his hold on his party and government would weaken without question. If the Congress loses in another landslide, it would be a grave setback for Rahul Gandhi at the start of his AICC presidency. A close defeat would be a decent start, but a victory would set him soaring and immediately make him a viable alternate for Modi at the national level.

The stakes are high for both sides, may the best man win. 

(Krishan Partap Singh is a novelist and a member of the Aam Aadmi Party.)

Disclaimer: The opinions expressed within this article are the personal opinions of the author. The facts and opinions appearing in the article do not reflect the views of NDTV and NDTV does not assume any responsibility or liability for the same.

Get Breaking news, live coverage, and Latest News from India and around the world on NDTV.com. Catch all the Live TV action on NDTV 24x7 and NDTV India. Like us on Facebook or follow us on Twitter and Instagram for latest news and live news updates.

NDTV Beeps - your daily newsletter

................................ Advertisement ................................

................................ Advertisement ................................

................................ Advertisement ................................