This Article is From Feb 07, 2019

"God Help You": CBI's Nageswara Rao Committed Contempt, Says Supreme Court

In the morning, the Centre got pulled up for transferring joint director AK Sharma. "How can he be transferred by the Centre when the Supreme Court said he must not be shifted?" the furious Chief Justice had questioned.

'God Help You': CBI's Nageswara Rao Committed Contempt, Says Supreme Court

M Nageswara Rao was appointed interim chief in the absence of Alok Verma as CBI chief


  • Top court was furious about laxity in abuse probe at Bihar shelter homes
  • AK Sharma - the CBI officer supervising the case - was shifted out
  • The court wanted the officer to stay incharge of the case
New Delhi:

Nageswara Rao, the former interim chief of the Central Bureau of Investigation, faced the wrath of the Supreme Court today for the transfer of an officer supervising a sensitive case involving the sexual abuse of children at Bihar's government-run shelter homes. Mr Rao, the top court said, was in contempt, since he was responsible for the transfer despite directions to the contrary. 

AK Sharma -- the officer supervising the sensitive case -- was shifted out as part of the overnight mass transfer that followed the public feud between the agency's former chief Alok Verma and his deputy Rakesh Asthana.

The court, which wanted the officer to stay in charge of the case, held Mr Rao responsible. Pointing out that the transfer was made despite its "embargo", the court questioned whether its directions were passed on to the appropriate authorities in charge of transfers. 

Remarking that Mr Rao and Bhasuran, the prosecution in-charge, have committed contempt, Chief Justice of India Ranjan Gogoi said, "You have played with our orders. God help you".

The Chief Justice had stepped into the three-judge bench after the recent retirement of Justice Madan Lokur. His first hearing of the case left him upset when the advocate representing the state government had no satisfactory answer to his queries. 

Finding out that Mr Sharma, the CBI's joint director in charge of the anti-corruption department, has been transferred, the Chief Justice said, "How can he be transferred by the Centre when the Supreme Court said he must not be shifted?" 

The agency was asked to inform the court in writing whether the panel which transfers officers, was aware of the "embargo" by 2 pm.

Later, the court said it appears that its order not to transfer Mr Sharma was not passed onto the Appointments Committee of the Cabinet. Mr Sharma was transferred along with five others, who were investigating six cases against Rakesh Asthana, days after the two top bosses of the agency were sent on leave.