At the house where the family of Yasin Bhatkal or Ahmed Siddibappa lives, we are told to put our cameras away. As a crowd gathers, the NDTV crew manages to slip into the Siddibappa household.
Persuading Yasin's father to speak is a task in itself. He says he does not want to be identified as a terrorist's father.
Zarar Siddibappa tells NDTV, "We have not seen him for seven years. He was an innocent boy when he was here. He went to Dubai to set up a business and disappeared from there.
Those seven years have been a nightmare for the family. "We have been ostracised here. No one speaks to us these days. Our relatives don't visit us. Everyone looks at our family with suspicion. We are dying a slow death every day," Mr Siddibappa, who is in his seventies, says.
He clings to the hope that the man arrested in north Bihar on Wednesday night is not his son Ahmed, who he describes as a "very nice boy when he was here." The father says, "I don't even know if it is my son. Today we got a notice from the police that they have arrested him. I have to see him to believe it is him."
Bhatkal's brother Samad, who was arrested mistakenly in 2010, lives in the same house. Mr Siddibappa said he was unnecessarily dragged into trouble.
"My life has been ruined forever after the arrest. Wherever I go I am a suspect. Now I just want to start a business on my own and move on with my life," said Samad.
On Thursday evening, just hours after his arrest, Bhatkal's uncle, in a statement, said that the family was relieved because "the truth will come out and our fears that he would be eliminated in a fake encounter have been put to rest."
Samad said the family is looking forward to meeting his brother. "We are happy he has been found after so many years. I don't believe the charges him are true. We are sure he is innocent. We are now looking forward to going and meeting him," he said.
Locals in Bhatkal hope they will not have to deal with another Yasin. The town desperately wants to move on. It wants to remove the terror tag it has lived with all these years. And the residents of Bhatkal hope Yasin's arrest will bring some closure.
Follow NDTV for latest election news and live coverage of assembly elections 2019 in Maharashtra and Haryana.
Subscribe to our YouTube channel, like us on Facebook or follow us on Twitter and Instagram for latest news and live news updates.