In diet discourse, potatoes often receive a short shrift. They're lumped into "bad carbs," blamed for weight gain, demonized in diabetes discussion, and banished from many slimming plans. Social media posts pit potatoes against so-called superfoods, and it has all got to the point where most Indians, no matter which region they hail from, now feel guilty about indulging in aloo paratha or aloo posto. But the scientific record tells a more nuanced story. Potatoes carry many nutrients, fibre (especially when eaten with skin), and potentially beneficial starch types which can support gut health and moderate glucose response when cooked smartly.
So, no, potatoes as an ingredient or part of the tuber family are not the enemy of your overall health and well-being. Here's every reason you need to know why, plus a deeper dive into how cooking potatoes in unhealthy ways is the real culprit.
Potato Nutrition: What's Inside the Tubers
Potatoes aren't just starch. According to Harvard Health, potatoes contribute notable amounts of potassium, vitamin C, vitamin B6, and a modest amount of dietary fibre, particularly in the peel.
A paper titled Perspective: Potatoes, Quality Carbohydrates, and Dietary Patterns frames potatoes as a "high-quality" carbohydrate when viewed in context, arguing that the potato's negative image often stems from overreliance on glycaemic index (GI) and overinterpretation of epidemiologic associations.
Understanding Variations In GI and Cooking Methods
What makes potatoes unique is that their glycaemic index is not fixed. It depends heavily on the variety and cooking method. In a study of North American potatoes, researchers found GI values ranging from 56 to 94, depending on type, e.g. boiled, baked, reheated, etc.
For instance, precooking and cooling potatoes, a process that increases resistant starch by retrogradation, reduced postprandial glucose response in trials. Another study with chilled potatoes showed that in women with elevated fasting glucose, chilled potatoes (higher in resistant starch) produced a lower glycaemic and insulin response compared to freshly cooked versions.
Resistant starch (RS) is a form of carbohydrate not digested in the small intestine but fermented in the colon. It exerts several physiological effects via gut microbiome and fermentation products. Another study with "novel resistant potato starches" (RS4) also showed lower post-meal glycaemic peaks and increased fullness ratings compared to control starches.
However, the evidence is mixed. A 2020 randomized study of RS2 supplementation in adults with prediabetes did not find significant improvements in satiety, food intake, or appetite. A more recent review of 22 studies found inconclusive evidence that RS reliably increases satiety or lowers intake.
Still, the pattern is clear: Cooking, cooling, and starch type adjustments can shift the metabolic impact of potatoes.
Photo Credit: Pexels
Are Potatoes Guilty Of Making You Gain Weight?
A 2019 study evaluated how different doses of potato intake affected body weight gain and food intake in animal models, and found that higher potato feeding led to greater weight gain under certain conditions.
More convincingly, experimental human trials of resistant starch supplementation (for example over 8 weeks) showed modest but significant average weight loss (around 2.8 kg) and improved insulin sensitivity in participants with overweight/obesity.
In Resistant Starch and Energy Balance, a review study on resistant starch research argues that RS may help reduce energy intake, increase fat oxidation, and mildly influence body composition, though results vary by dose, duration, and individual metabolic context.
Potato Consumption And Diabetes Risk: What Science Says
Much of the fear around potatoes comes from observational epidemiology, but recent and higher-resolution cohort data help refine the story.
In a large recent pooled analysis published in 2025, researchers followed 205,107 participants over many years (22,299 developed type 2 diabetes). They found that French fries (fried potatoes) were associated with a 20% higher risk per three servings weekly, whereas combined baked/boiled/mashed potatoes showed no significant association with T2D risk after adjusting for body mass index and other factors.
They also modelled substitution effects: replacing three servings/week of potatoes with whole grains was estimated to lower T2D risk, 8% lower for total potatoes, 4% for baked/boiled/mashed, and 19% for French fries.
Harvard's own commentary notes that the risk associated with potatoes seems heavily dependent on cooking method. The message: "how they're prepared, and what they're replacing" matters more than an absolute "good or bad" label.
Earlier studies also implicated potato consumption (particularly fried) and T2D risk, like the Halton et al. Nurses' Health Study, which showed stronger associations for French fries than for boiled potatoes, especially after controlling for BMI.
What All This Means: The Cooking Method Is the Pivot
From this body of evidence, several practical conclusions about potatoes emerge:
- The potato itself, boiled, baked, or cooled to raise resistant starch, is not inherently harmful and can be metabolically more benign.
- Deep-frying, smothering in saturated fats, and pairing with refined carbs shift potatoes from "neutral" to risk-laden.
- Portion size, varietal selection, cooling/retrogradation, and pairing (fibre, protein) modulate potato's effect on glucose and weight.
- Substituting French fries with whole grains can meaningfully reduce type 2 diabetes risk, per substitution models in cohort data.
Photo Credit: Pexels
How To Use Potatoes Wisely In A Healthy Diet
Based on the above evidence, here are some basic guidelines on how to use potatoes in a healthy, balanced diet.
- Boil, Bake, Steam, Chill: Use cooking methods that minimize added fat and enhance resistant starch (cooling after cooking).
- Eat With Skin On: Potato peel contributes dietary fibre and phytonutrients.
- Mind Portion Sizes: A single medium potato often suffices; avoid oversized servings.
- Pair Wisely: Consume with legumes, vegetables, or protein to slow glycaemic response.
- Avoid Fried Preparations: French fries, chips, and deep-fried potato dishes are strongly associated with increased metabolic risk.
- Use Variety And Rotation: Alternate with whole grains, millets, or tubers like sweet potato for diversity.
- Apply Substitution Wisdom: Swap out fried or high-potato meals with whole-grain or legume-based dishes to reduce long-term risk.
Potatoes, Rehabilitated When Cooked Right
Potatoes have been unfairly cast as a dietary villain. The science makes it clear that the tuber itself is not the enemy, bad cooking, large portions, and unhealthy pairings are. When boiled, baked, or cooled, in modest quantities and wisely paired, potatoes can fit into a healthy, balanced diet.
The narrative should shift from "potatoes are bad" to "choose better methods, pair wisely, control portions." Let the potato rise above its unfair reputation, not as a dietary scapegoat, but as a balanced, flexible food you can enjoy without guilt.
Disclaimer: This content including advice provides generic information only. It is in no way a substitute for a qualified medical opinion. Always consult a specialist or your own doctor for more information. NDTV does not claim responsibility for this information.
