"I've seen a lot of fish, and a lot of big fish, but I've never seen anything like it," he says. He estimates that the unidentified fish was between 1.5 to 1.7 meters long - or approximately 5-feet-long.
Riley Lindholm shared pictures of the fish on a public forum in order to identify it.
"There's a fair bit of speculation - it could have been a cod, could have been a groper, and one guy I think might have nailed it when he said it was what they call a tripletail," said Mr Lindholm to ABC News.
When Mr Lindholm returned to the beach the next day, the fish was gone.
The ocean is TERRIFYING. https://t.co/DJCNLSOv6O- shan (@shanbennet) March 8, 2018
I for one do not welcome our new fish overlords. https://t.co/DiFXE3cxla- Em-Roe (@EmilyHyphenRose) March 8, 2018
It's Extraterrestrial- FreeSpeech4All (@AndyPandy3702) March 8, 2018
Authorities say that definitive identification of the fish could be difficult.
Click for more trending news