Tata-Mistry case: The Supreme Court said the decision to remove Cyrus Mistry was right
In a major victory for the Tata Group, the Supreme Court on Friday set aside the NCLAT (National Company Law Tribunal) order restoring Cyrus Mistry as the executive chairman of the conglomerate. A bench of Chief Justice SA Bobde and Justices AS Bopanna and V Ramasubramanian said it is allowing the appeals filed by Tata Group. "The order of NCLAT dated December 18, 2019 is set aside," the bench said. "All the questions of law are liable to be answered in favour of the appellants Tata Group and the appeals filed by the Tata Group are liable to be allowed and those by Shapoorji Pallonji Group are liable to be dismissed," the top court said.
Chronology Of Events in Tata Group - Cyrus Mistry Case
- October 24, 2016: Cyrus Mistry was ousted as Tata Sons Chairman, Ratan Tata named as an interim Chairman of the group
- December 20: Two Cyrus Mistry-family backed investment firms - Cyrus Investments Pvt Ltd and Sterling Investments Corporation Pvt Ltd - move NCLT Mumbai, alleging oppression of minority shareholders and mismanagement by Tata Sons. They also challenged Cyrus Mistry's removal.
- January 12, 2017: Tata Sons names N Chandrashekaran as Chairman, the then TCS Chief Executive Officer and Managing Director.
- February 6, 2017: Cyru Mistry was removed as a director of the board of Tata Sons, holding company of Tata group.
- March 6, 2017: NCLT Mumbai sets aside plea of the two investment firms of Cyrus Mistry family over maintainability issue, citing they didn't meet the criteria of 10 per cent ownership in a company for the filing of a case of alleged oppression of minority shareholders under the Companies Act. The Mistry family owns 18.4 per cent stake in the closely-held Tata Sons but the holding is less than 3 per cent if preferential shares are excluded.
- April 17, 2017: NCLT Mumbai also rejects plea by the two investment firms seeking waiver in the criteria of having at least 10 per cent ownership in a company for filing case of alleged oppression of minority shareholders.
- Apr 27, 2017: Investment firms move NCLAT, challenging NCLT order which rejected their petitions over maintainability. They also challenged rejection of their waiver plea.
- September 21, 2017: NCLAT allows pleas by the two investment firms seeking waiver in filing case of oppression and mismanagement against Tata Sons. It, however, dismissed Cyrus Mistry's other petition on maintainability saying the firms do not have more than 10 per cent in Tata Sons. The appellate tribunal directs the Mumbai-bench of the NCLT to issue notice and proceed in the matter.
- October 5, 2017: Two investment firms approach the principal bench of NCLT at Delhi, seeking transfer of the matter from Mumbai to Delhi citing likelihood of bias. The principal bench reserves order on the plea of the two investment firms.
- October 6, 2017: Principal bench of NCLT dismisses the pleas and imposed a cost of Rs 10 lakh on the two investment firms, which was to be shared by both.
- July 9, 2018: NCLT Mumbai dismisses pleas of Mistry challenging his removal as Tata Sons chairman as also the allegations of rampant misconduct on part of Ratan Tata and the company's Board. NCLT said it found no merit in his allegations of mismanagement in Tata group firms.
- August 3, 2018: Two investment firms approach NCLAT against the order of the NCLT dismissing his plea challenging his removal as chairman of the company.
- August 29, 2018: NCLAT admits petition filed by Cyrus Mistry in his personal capacity and decided to hear along with the main petitions filed by the two investment firms.
- May 23, 2019: NCLAT reserves its order after completing the hearing in the matter.
- December 18, 2019: NCLAT restores Mistry as executive chairman of Tata Sons, but suspended its implementation for four weeks in order to provide time for Tatas to appeal.
- January 2, 2020: Tata Sons, challenges NCLAT decision of December 18, 2019 before Supreme Court.
- January 10, 2020: Supreme Court stays NCLAT decision.
- September 22, 2020: Supreme Court restrains Shapoorji Pallonji Group from pledging its share in Tata Sons.
- December 8, 2020: Final hearing in the dispute commences.
- December 17, 2020: Supreme Court reserves verdict in the dispute.
- March 26, 2021: Supreme Court delivers its verdict, allows Tata Group's appeals and sets aside NCLAT order restoring Cyrus Mistry as executive chairman of the Group.