Mughals Out, Mahakumbh In: What Has Changed In New NCERT Class 7 Books
Asked about the new NCERT textbook, Union Minister Sukanta Majumdar has said the Mughal era has not been removed, but only repetitive content has been edited out.
The new social science textbook for Class 7 students following NCERT's curriculum has no references to the Mughal rule and the Delhi Sultanate. Earlier, NCERT -- the National Council of Educational Research and Training -- had trimmed sections on the Mughals and Delhi Sultanate. This time, they have disappeared entirely.
The new textbooks have been prepared in line with the new National Education Policy and National Curriculum Framework for School Education, 2023.
5 Themes, 12 Chapters
The twelve chapters in the textbook are categorised under five themes. Under the first theme, 'India and the World: Land and the People' are three chapters -- Geographical Diversity of India, Understanding the Weather and Climates of India. The next theme is 'Tapestry of the Past'; the chapters are New Beginnings: Cities and States, The Rise of Empires, The Age of Reorganisation and The Gupta Era: An Age of Tireless Creativity. The third theme is 'Our Cultural Heritage and Knowledge Traditions', with one chapter: How the Land Becomes Sacred.
The fourth theme is 'Governance and Democracy' and the chapters are From the Rulers to the Ruled: Types of Governments and The Constitution of India - An Introduction. The fifth and final theme is 'Economic Life Around Us'; this has two chapters -- From Barter to Money and Understanding Markets.
Photo Credit: Courtesy: NCERT
What's In
Starting with the Harappan era and Janapadas and Mahajanapadas, the textbook moves to The Rise of Empires, where it talks about the ancient Magadha kingdom. It then refers to the arrival of the Greeks led by Alexander the Great. The textbook then details the creation of the Maurya Empire and chronicles the rise of Chandragupta Maurya and Ashoka, and life during the Mauryan era. The next chapter, The Age of Reorganisation, talks about Shungas, Satavahanas, Chedis, Cholas, Cheras, Pandyas and Kushanas. There is a chapter on the Gupta era that showcases governance, administration and trade during that period.
The next chapter is How The Land Becomes Sacred and mentions key sites associated with all the religions followed in India. This chapter has a section on the Kumbh Mela and details its mythological origin. It also mentions that the Kumbh Mela this year drew a crowd of 660 million. The next chapter focuses on the government and its three arms -- Executive, Legislature and Judiciary. It also draws a comparison between different forms of rule -- democracy, monarchy, theocracy, dictatorships and oligarchy.
Photo Credit: Courtesy: NCERT
What's Out
The NCERT social science textbook for 2024-25 had a detailed section on the rulers of Delhi and included sections on the administration under the Khaljis and the Tughluqs. It also had a chapter on the Mughals and detailed administration under their rule in the 16th and 17th centuries.
The chapter on Mughals introduced the dynasty, detailed their military campaigns, their traditions on succession and their relationships with other rulers. It spoke about Mansabdars, Jagirdars and the Zamindari system.
It must, however, be pointed out that these chapters were in the part-2 textbook for Class 7 students, and the one released for this year is part-1. According to reports, officials have said that the second part is likely to be released in a few months, but they have not commented on whether the second part will include the history of the Mughals and Delhi Sultanate rulers.
Photo Credit: Courtesy: NCERT
What Ministers Said
Asked about the new NCERT textbook, Union Minister Sukanta Majumdar has said the Mughal era has not been removed from the book, but only repetitive content has been edited out. "It has not been dropped. Repetition has been removed. Repetition should not be there," said Mr Majumdar, the Minister of State for Education.
"The Mughal era is an important part of Indian history. Similar importance should be given to the other era also, the one which was India's golden period," he said, adding that the Mughal period is "the darkest part of Indian history."
Defence Minister Rajnath Singh recently pointed to the "glorification" of Mughal ruler Aurangzeb in Indian history textbooks. "In our history books, even a cruel and ruthless ruler like Aurangzeb has been presented in a glorified manner. Due to this distorted history, some people attempt to portray Aurangzeb as a hero," he said.
The 'Saffronisation' Debate
The missing Mughals in the Class 7 textbook are likely to rekindle the allegations of saffronisation against the Narendra Modi government. Opposition parties and social outfits have been accusing the government of tweaking history books for political objectives.
The government, including Education Minister Dharmendra Pradhan, has trashed these allegations and maintained that there is no plan to erase anything from history books, but it has stressed that India's history lessons cannot be restricted to the victories of "Mughal aggressors" and claimed a Western influence in the earlier education system.
Right-wing outfits have often spoken about reclaiming Hindu temples destroyed during the Mughal rule and alleged that Hindu rulers did not get adequate importance in history books. Recently, emotions ran high after Bollywood movie Chhava, which told the story of Maratha ruler Chhatrapati Sambhaji Maharaj. Multiple BJP leaders had then demanded the removal of the Mughal emperor Aurangzeb's tomb from Maharashtra.
-
Opinion | The Vijay Paradox: How A 'Welfare State' Still Ended Up Dissatisfied
The TVK will have to go the extra mile to deliver the goods, over and above the DMK's slew of welfarist measures that were generally comfortable, but not enough. The voter simply said, 'Yeh Dil Maange More'.
-
Opinion | Congress' Biggest Challenge For Kerala? Not Letting It Go Down The Karnataka Way
The Congress has to ensure this does not end up becoming another Rajasthan or Karnataka-like leadership tussle. In neighbouring Karnataka, the Congress finds itself split down the middle.
-
Opinion | Mamata Banerjee Brought Down The Left, But Never Quite Learnt From Its Fall
Mamata took over the Left's playbook 15 years ago, but failed to rework it to craft a new politics. In the end, the people of Bengal got more of the same: musclemen, corruption, and bad governance.
-
Opinion | MK Stalin: The Strongman Who Underestimated His Opponent - And Paid The Price
The DMK ecosystem kept dismissing Vijay's supporters as "tharkuris", that is, "idiots". It's this short-sightedness they are now paying for.
-
Left Behind? Left Not In Power In Any State For 1st Time In 50 Years
When the first elections were held in the country in 1951-52, it was the Communist Party of India that had the highest number of seats among Opposition parties in the Lok Sabha.
-
Opinion | Self-Inflicted Wounds? How Mamata Became The Architect Of Her Own Collapse
For a leader who built her identity on being the "sole protector" of Bengali sub-nationalism and the provider of a sprawling welfare state, the transition to the Opposition benches will be devastating.
-
Beaten In Their Backyards: Is This The End For Mamata Banerjee, MK Stalin?
Mamata Banerjee and MK Stalin faced major defeats in their home states - the BJP made history by dominating Bengal and actor Vijay made history in Tamil Nadu with his successful cinema-to-politics jump.
-
Analysis | The V-Team: What Vijay's Game-Changing 'Cabinet Of Firsts' May Look Like
High-profile names such as KA Sengottaiyan and JCD Prabhakar are expected to provide the necessary experience ballast, while figures such as Aadhav Arjuna, KG Arunraj, and CTR Nirmal Kumar represent the new guard of strategic thinkers.
-
Opinion | What Our 'Liberals' Really Need To Understand About Bengal's Voters
When it comes to Bengal, 'liberal' standards tend to quickly bend. Principles are replaced by poetry. Accountability by abstraction. Cases that would provoke nationwide outrage elsewhere are treated with caution, sometimes even scepticism.
