Did a government officer, in charge of a Home Ministry probe to look for missing papers in the Ishrat Jahan case, tutor witnesses on what to say? That's what a sensational report in the Indian Express claimed today. The officer in question has denied this strongly while former Home Minister P Chidambaram says it's a vindication of his position. As the politics gets uglier, will we ever get to the bottom of this story? We debate on Left, Right and Centre.