Members of the non-profit group soon found some people who claimed they saw what happened to the animals.
The four dogs and a pup were first tied up and sprayed with diesel before setting them on fire, the people who claimed to have seen the horrific act said. The dogs were left howling in pain as the fire engulfed them, the people told members of the Action for Animals Against Cruelty and Trauma or AaCT.
On September 28, a man was seen feeding rotis to the dogs, which is now suspected to be poisoned food meant to kill the animals.
AaCT member Neena Rai said local workers have claimed they saw some people from a nearby office tying the limbs of four dogs and dragging them for some 50 metres before setting them on fire.
"There is so much crime and senseless killings of animals happening in this city," AaCT chief Meher Mathrani said. "I met with senior police officers... We have been asking for a special nodal office for animal welfare," Mr Mathrani said.
The animal welfare group said the police must take crime against animals seriously. "Letters have been sent from high-ranking officers from the central government to support animal welfare officers... these directions don't seem to have filtered through to the city police," Mr Mathrani said.