Amrapali Diverted Homebuyers' Money To Firm Linked To MS Dhoni: Auditors
Top court has directed NBCC to complete stalled Amrapali Group projects Auditors say Amrapali Group entered into several agreements with Rhiti Rhiti Sports Management promotes brand of cricketer MS Dhoni
Amrapali Group had entered into "sham agreements" with Rhiti Sports Management Pvt Ltd (RSMPL) - which promotes the brand of cricketer Mahendra Singh Dhoni - to "illegally divert" homebuyers' money, forensic auditors told the Supreme Court. In its report, accepted by the top court on Tuesday, the court-appointed auditors said that Amrapali Sapphire Developers Pvt Ltd had paid Rs 6.52 crore to Rhiti Sports Management during 2009-2015, out of the total amount of Rs 42.22 crore.
Several agreements were entered into by Amrapali Group with Rhiti Sports Management, including one of November 22, 2009, under which MS Dhoni would make himself available to the chairman for three days along with one representative of RSMPL, the report added.
"There are no documents held on record for compliance of this condition," forensic auditors Ravi Bhatia and Pawan Kumar Aggarwal said in their report.
"This clearly shows that these agreements have just been made for payment of amounts to Rhiti Sports Management Private Limited Company are sham agreements and made just for making payments to RSMPL," the report said.
"We feel that homebuyers' money has been diverted illegally and wrongly to RSMPL and should be recovered from them as the said agreement in our opinion does not stand the test of law," the forensic auditors said in their finding, which was noted by a bench of Justices Arun Mishra and UU Lalit in its 270-page verdict.
In April this year, MS Dhoni moved the apex court seeking protection of his ownership rights on an over 5,500-square-feet penthouse he had booked 10 years ago in a project of Amrapali Group.
The report said that Amrapali Saphire paid Rs 6.52 crore on account of the agreements executed by Amrapali CMD Anil Kumar Sharma with Rhiti Sports Management.
"There is no resolution on record authorising Anil Kumar Sharma, CMD to enter into an agreement on behalf of all Amrapali group of Companies," the auditors said.
The report also dealt with an agreement for sponsorship dated March 20, 2015, under which Amrapali Group of Companies got the right to advertise as Logo Space at various places in the IPL 2015 for Chennai Super Kings.
"It is observed that this agreement is on plain paper and executed only between Amrapali and Rhiti Sports Management Private Limited and there are no signatories on behalf of Chennai Super Kings to this agreement. No resolution in favour of Arun Pandey, signatory of Rhiti Sports Management Private Limited, is attached with the said agreement," the auditors said.
They said MS Dhoni, whose wife Sakshi Singh Dhoni was a director in Amrapali Mahi Developers Pvt Ltd, was the brand ambassador of Amrapali Group and carried out a number of transactions with respect to endorsement of its projects. He has entered in agreements with other group companies as well.
It said Amrapali Mahi Developers Pvt Ltd was incorporated for development of a project in Ranchi and a memorandum of understanding (MoU) was also entered between the parties.
The auditors found that Amrapali Sapphire Developers Private Limited has booked a flat in the name of RSMPL by passing an adjustment entry.
"However, Sanjay Pandey of Rhiti Sports Management Pvt Ltd denied booking of any such flat. He also confirmed that neither the company nor any individual has any flat in Amrapali Group. Pandey confirmed that no due diligence was carried out before accepting the brand endorsement though he informed that brand value and paying capacity was seen," the report said.
"No agreement was provided, though it was agreed that it would be provided by March 11, 2019. Expenses were reimbursed to Rhiti Entertainment Private Limited, a group company, without any agreement," the finding of auditors said.
Rhiti Group said in a statement, "With utmost respect to the orders of Supreme Court, we would only like to clarify that the observation mentioned in a forensic report are bereft of proper information or relevant documents. The company has been in possession of all information and relevant documents that can establish the clean image and that the observations made in the said report are incorrect."
The group said, "Rhiti has been an endorsement agency for world class talent and was retained by Amrapali Group due to its fair and transparent business dealings in 2009. The question of siphoning funds does not arise because Rhiti provided all professional services as per the agreement, and the then pre-agreed endorsement fee received from Amrapali was paid to relevant endorsing staff and celebrity."
"We have legitimate business claim of approximately Rs 40 crore against Amrapali Group and towards the recovery of the same, we are before the Supreme Court," RSMPL said.
On Tuesday, cracking its whip on errant builders for breaching the trust reposed by homebuyers, the top court cancelled the registration of Amrapali under the real estate law RERA (Real Estate Regulation Act), and ousted it from its prime properties in the NCR by nixing the land leases.
The Supreme Court, which directed a probe by the Enforcement Directorate into alleged money laundering by realtors, provided relief to over 42,000 home buyers of Amrapali Group with the verdict.
The top court directed the state-run National Buildings Construction Corporation (NBCC) to complete stalled projects of the realtor, whose directors Anil Kumar Sharma, Shiv Priya and Ajay Kumar are behind the bars on its order.