» Story
 
  SocialTwist Tell-a-Friend
BT brinjal: A new special on menus?
NDTV Correspondent, Wednesday October 14, 2009, Hyderabad

It could be coming soon to a plate near you. Genetically-modified (GM) brinjal has been given the thumbs up by a committee of experts. Now it's upto the government to decide whether BT brinjal, as it's known, can be commercially released.

The Genetic Engineering Approval Committee (GEAC), the biotechnology regulatory body of the Government of India, has been studying BT brinjal, amid opposition from food experts and civil groups. They point out that there's not enough research to predict the long-term impact of GM food on either humans or the environment. Most countries in Europe do not permit GM food.

"I am not satisfied with the way the study has been conducted. I wanted a scientific debate. We don't know what the long term impact of this could be," laments Dr Pushpa Bhargava, molecular biologist and member of the GEAC.

The genetic material of GM crops is altered to help either producers or consumers. In India, BT cotton is the only commercially approved biotech crop. BT brinjal has been developed by The Maharashtra Hybrid Seed Company (Mahyco). It's been tweaked to resist a particular strain of pest that affects the vegetable.

Mahcyo argues that BT brinjal helps farmers because it's sturdier, and therefore results in higher yield, while allowing them to save on pesticides. "Bt brinjal is going to increase yield by 100 per cent. It will reduce pesticide consumption to the extent of 60 per cent," explains M K Sharma, General Manager, Mahyco.

Supporters of BT brinjal say BT cotton has been a big success. They quote statistics that show BT cotton helped India to become the world's second-largest producer and exporter of cotton.

Speaking on the development, Environment Minister Jairam Ramesh said, "I won't be under pressure from anyone to take a decision and will study the panel's report before giving clearance."
 
 
More »
 
SocialTwist Tell-a-Friend     
Comments: Read | Post
Comments
Posted by Vimal Kishen on Oct 18, 2009
Why dont we learn from history? Monsanto's Bt Cotton is responsible for large number of cotton farmer suicides in Vidharbha region. These farmers never had to buy seeds to sow their land, but with GM cotton, the farmers were forced to buy seeds every season! The same will happen with Bt Brinjal or any other vegetable that is GM. Moreover GM vegetables may give us better yield, but they do not possess many traits related to reisitance against pests that native varities have. Its time Monsanto Seeds are banned from India. Jai Hind.
Posted by Pratibha Chauhan on Oct 15, 2009
Its really nice to see so many Indians coming forward at such a crucial time and contributing by whatever means we could, we all know to some extent that GM food are not the safest thing for human consumption and to push this upon society is pure greed and nothing else. Prominent scientist Prof Seralini ( same guy upon whose recommendation EU is GM free) advised GEAC but they have ignored his recommendations and approved the Bt Brinjal. He famously said that if India approves of GM crops then a major health crisis is awaiting the whole world. Thing is cancer rates in US is unprecedented thanks to GM foods and believe it or not they don't even label their products as GM food, how ridiculous, and a word of advice for Kunal, read up on GM food before you post comments like that, gain some knowledge, Indians are not so naive as Americans. lastly guys, I know we are all doing our part to stop GM food but at the same time I have confidence in our politicians that they will eventually approve GM crops as they have never cared about people and once that happen we must only buy GM free food . I have no doubt that we can collectively beat Monsanto and likes. May god give us strength... Pratibha
Advertisement
Advertisement
On Facebook