»  SciDev Eye  »   Post
Dream Cabinet may shore up Indian Science
Tuesday June 2, 2009

Science it seems has finally come of age in India as hugely qualified and politically heavyweight ministers have been appointed for key portfolios like science, environment and education in the new government.

Prithviraj Chavan (63), a mechanical engineer from University of California, Berkeley, who spent his early years making electronic components for listening in on enemy submarines in America, was appointed as the new Science Minister. A heavyweight politician from Western India who on assuming office said, "My first love is science and technology." Chavan will certainly have a heavy workload as he now has to handle as many as five different ministries.

Earlier, when the world's largest democracy, which voted through a robust gift of Indian science -- the Electronic Voting Machine -- gave an economist Prime Minister Manmohan Singh another five year term in office, among his many poll promises was, "We will carry out a massive renewal of science and technology infrastructure." Speaking on the issue, a soft-spoken Chavan said, "Funds will not be short." Chavan feels his second hat as minister in the PMO will help him get 'new and big ideas' across to Singh himself. Chavan for the time becomes a single point person for almost all Indian scientific departments as he is also a member of the secretive cash rich Atomic Energy Commission; and the Space Commission -- the highest policy making bodies for these strategic departments.

Widely regarded as one of the 'best science minister India ever had', lawyer-turned-politician, Kapil Sibal (61), has now been appointed the new Minister for Education with a Cabinet rank, a huge elevation in his profile as the top man at the Human Resources Development Ministry. This is a much coveted portfolio since Singh's government has gone in for a massive expansion of higher education. Speaking about his responsibilities, Sibal said, "He hoped for a synergy in science and education like never before." Dubbing it a 'very welcome confluence' M Vijayan, a biophysicist and president of the Indian National Science Academy, New Delhi, said, "Barriers and vertical silos need to be broken if Indian science has to flourish especially in universities." He also dubbed Sibal's term as science minister as the time when 'science did extra ordinarily well'.

With the specter of climate change looming large and important international negotiations on the horizon, an articulate mechanical engineer, Jairam Ramesh (55) who has studied at Indian Institute of Technology, Mumbai, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Boston and completed a MS from Carnegie Melon University in Program Management was appointed as the new environment and forests minister. Making the country's position on climate change amply clear, he immediately said, "India cannot take on any binding emissions reduction targets." He also feels that a country which accounts for 16 per cent of the world's population and accounts for a mere five per cent of the emissions, could not be expected to stop its rapid economic growth and development. Incidentally, Ramesh, a power minister in the last administration, had emphasised that clean coal, hydel and nuclear will be the mainstay for energising India.

The Chairman of the Scientific Advisory Council to the Prime Minister and a solid-state chemist, Professor CNR Rao, lauded these appointments saying, "This constellation (of ministers) is the best combination I have ever seen." Rao had recently emphasised that 'the mood is so positive (that now) we the professional scientists should not let them down'.

Also, applauding the Prime Minister's commitment for reposing faith in Indian science through these highly skilled new appointees, Thirumalachari Ramasami, a chemist and Secretary of the Department of Science and Technology, New Delhi, said, "This was a moment of great expectation." His immediate wishlist submitted to the government includes a quick tripling of the science base in India. "We now have a dream team," feels technocrat Samir K Brahmachari, who is a structural biologist and Director General of the Council of Scientific and Industrial Research, New Delhi who adds "now we have no choice but to deliver".

 
   SocialTwist Tell-a-Friend
Comments: Read | Post
Comments Post your comments
 
Posted by DR T RADJAKOUMAR on Jun 08, 2009
Please give DST/CSIR a new organizational structure with public and private equity and selection of scientists on time bound projects with out a permanent hierarchical structure
 
Posted by Karan on Jun 05, 2009
This is just a fantasy, we Indians are good at fantasing which has been going on for last 50-60 yrs. The height of talking big has crossed all the limits in last 4-5 yrs with little accomplishments. Let us start with our over hyped IIT's, worshipped by almost every literate Indian. What these institutions have contributed anything worthwhile in the developments of India. Offcourse most of IIT graduates have done well for themselves, atleast by Indian standard. Let us understand that it is just a dream at best to expect any breakthrough in Science and Technology. God help India and its people, specially the unfortunate poor.
 
 
Posted by vijay on Jun 03, 2009
I have been reading and closely watching the developments politically , economically and statistically every trumpeting from there own point of view or experience or ill experience but what india needs is not only leaders politically / qualification / experience but impementors with core efficiency and conviction we always need to find a solution from with in to whatever problem we face because india is unique in all angles so a solution suitable for another country or society will not be suitable for us so all of the countrymen should try to educate ourselves as much as possible and cooperate in for the well being of the nation as a whole and for the man kind . I would like to lure every countrymen and woman to participate to make our country a self sufficient and self reliant developed nation. hoping for the best and with all my support ,dedication and conviction.
 
Posted by Kunal on Jun 03, 2009
but still Kashmir wil be the core issue for which no scinece has been developed yet....Alas..!somebody lost home..
 
Posted by CSIR fellow on Jun 03, 2009
Sadly, I happened to be part of a CSIR lab. Only way to rise is sycophancy. You can be promoted without any scientific achievement and it is a chain. Some of the appointment are worthless...some people dont even deserve to be technicians forget about scientist. There are many examples such in Molecular Biology Division (I happened to be in pharmacology) such as D V AMLA who has become Sci G because he knows how to please NBRI director Rakesh Tuli. He is big chamcha and dreaming to become director and he has published 7-8 papers in his whole career. So Manmohan Singh team should work on accountability.
 
Posted by Dr. B. P. Pandey on Jun 03, 2009
I wholeheartedly agree with Dr. Srinivasan. Every one who has done a bit of serious science knows that organizations like DST, CSIR etc. are perfect graveyard of science as they are filled with "corrupt mediocre people" without any accountability. To give an example, I spent sometime at a DST run Indian Institute of Geomagnetism in Bombay and found that only career progression path there is sycophancy. I was stunned to discover that most of the professors there do not publish anything, year after year. All they need to do is just please some idiot who is either director or DST boss. And with some luck, not work, they become director also. Without any accountability, DST and CSIR institutions are just white elephants. And given that people can get away with a statue of their own (like CNR Rao) using right kind of political connection it is hard to see how a minister can rectify these 'scientists'. Only way forward is to close these white elephants like DST , CSIR etc and reorganize the whole show. Else with each passing year, we will continue slipping behind in Asia and our universities will not be even among top 100.
 
Posted by srikanta on Jun 03, 2009
Its a fantastic combination which has been created. Hope they coordinate well and deliver soon.
 
Posted by JEYABAL on Jun 03, 2009
I only wish this Manmohan team do nat again resort to importing solutions from abroad for the native problems. Any team would work and deliver solutions only when they recognise the real problem in any field. After all to find a solution you should have a problem at the first instance. Quickfix 'solutions' from abroad shall never solve our problems, rather result in the drain of our resources and waste of precious time. This manmohan team should not become parochial in its approach to others ideas, since it has a majority of their own.Again this team should deliver to the indians as a whole and not partially. Consensus should be the watch word. This majority again should not breed arrogance. It is this arrogance in some quarters made them bite the dust in the hustings and not otherwise.
 
Posted by sanjeev on Jun 03, 2009
What Indian wants ROTI, KAPRA AUR MAKAN I sure new team will reduce the prices of essential commodities so that people can eat something. As regards to minister qualification is concern this will defiantly help him to control bureaucrat because ultimately they are running the government and they always that advantage of knowledge.
 
Posted by Rohan Mishra on Jun 03, 2009
Thanks for reinstating the faith in the progress we expect in Sceince & Tech as also R & D in India. What I would be keen to know and have details on is the stance of the ministers elect on HIV/AIDS prevention & vaccine development in India. Will be happy to hear what our minsters/ secretaries have to say on the issue which is impending as the biggest pandemic in the health space in India. Thanks
 
Posted by Dr.G.Srinivasan on Jun 02, 2009
Science progresses not only because of the minister and encouragement given by the government but also the environment created by the scientists themselves.A brain drained India will not be of much use in this scenario.Even if the brain drain were to be reversed the circumstances prevalent will not allow good science to be done. This is from personal experience-- I am a neuropeptide chemist trained from Karolinska and I had to forget this and bank on my basic medical profession for a living . The circumstances were created by jealous people in ICMR, DST, CSIR and all places which had anything to do with science. They are packed with corrupt mediocre people who have no idea of what science is all about . Science is a beautiful tree which can grow only when all the criteria are there. Now we have a gardner . But technology does not mean science .there is a subtle difference
 
Posted by Mahesh on Jun 02, 2009
Dear Sir, All this hype about minister being qualified do not hold anything but a big Zero when the professed policy of the Governments in the past is to go reserving the educational facilities for vote bank politics than catering to Merit. We all know to succeed in Science and technology we need meritorious students not students with passing percentages to carry forward the scientific inquisitions. Hope we as a country wake up to this fact sooner before it is too late.
 
Posted by Anonymous on Jun 02, 2009
All this is fine, what about poverty? malnutrition? Female Infanticide? Corruption? Inequality?...these are all fundamental human problems which warrant immediate attention, more so than science and technology. I am a mathematician myself yet I still say that solving fundamental human problem is far more important.
 
Posted by Akshut on Jun 02, 2009
I hope this works..... . Let us teach fellow Indians to have less kids..
 
Posted by gopal kumar choudhary on Jun 02, 2009
dear sir, thank you very much for such a good peace of writing. i am totally agree with you that this jumbo minister has every good quality to be a minister and i am sure that they will deliver the best under the prime minister Dr. manmohan sing who himself known as a great economist.there are many more ministers in every departments except few one and that i call the beauty of democracy. each and every body should know his responsibility then only they can deliver and they have because after such a long period of time Indian voters has given a clear mandate in such a crucial time. as far as ministries is concern education is most important and fortunately we have good bunch of leaders in ministries with good academic records for example we have the combination of oxford, haward, st.Stephens, presidency college, iit's.Mit Boston etc.so lets hope for better delivery this time by the manmohan sing and his entire gang..... thanks. gopalkumarchoudhary@gmail.com
 
Posted by Janaki on Jun 02, 2009
Team Manmohan with special emphasis on Science and Technology should provide for development in Agricultural production,pollution free environment,ample power supply,clean water,good infra structure and advanced space research.Well qualified young brains in science and technology should be used for good progress and development of our country,providing better living conditions in our own land.
 
Posted by Sangamesh on Jun 02, 2009
I wish this hope should come true..We always had the much hopes and more plans.. we saw the failure at the end of five year term of power. Now i am looking for delivary of our hopes...this time it looks good mix of ministers(experiance and young people mix). It has given me more hope and proud as well.. now i am waiting for the fast delivery of the works especialy transport(Infrastructure) and education sector.
 
 
Post Your Comments Fields marked with * are mandatory
*Name:
E-mail:
*Comments:
  Limit 4000 characters - 4000 characters remaining
*Secure Code:
  Problem viewing this image. Click to refresh
 
 
Kindly do not post any defamatory, infringing, obscene, indecent, discriminatory or unlawful material or information. NDTV Convergence Ltd reserves the right to remove without notice any content received from users.
 
Advertisement
Advertisement
On Facebook
About Me
Pallava Bagla, Science Editor of NDTV is a globally acclaimed science communicator. Winner of India's highest award for science journalism in 2005 and conferred the 'Outstanding Journalism' award by the United Nations in 2003. Author of several books, the latest being 'Destination Moon: India's Quest for Moon, Mars and Beyond' published by HarperCollins. His pioneering multi media campaign in making Chandrayaan-1, truly a people's mission got critical acclaim.
Latest Posts
The Untouchables: Bombay Police after 26/11
There is a story the officers of Bombay police like to tell: of brotherhood, risk and the fight against evil.
Ever-reddy
For the Reddys to be hailed as only the kings of Bellary, was galling. Their sights were set over controlling north Karnataka.
Tawang, in preparation
Tawang is in bridal makeup. Dressed for the occasion to receive their Spiritual Guru. It's a pretty picture of festivity.