»  Heart of the Matter  »   Post
Cast a farce
Friday April 17, 2009 , Bijoynagar, India

Villagers descend from an Indian Air Force AN 32 aircraft at the Advance Landing Ground (ALG) in Vijaynagar in Changlang district of Arunachal Pradesh. Vijaynagar is the only circle in Changlang sistrict of Arunachal Pradesh which is fully mantained by ai

This is how inclusive Indian democracy is. Look at Arunachal Pradesh. Poll officials have travelled for days to places in Lumta, Pakke, Anini and Bordumsa which has just 3 voters each. In other parts like Tawang, Kurun Kumey, Upper Subansiri, Mechuka and Anjaw officials have walked on foot for three days after travelling on elephant back crossing rivers .690 polling personnel had to be transported by helicopter. Polling has been held at Thingbu at an altitude of 12, 148 ft and Luguthhand at 13,157 ft.

Indian elections overcome impossible logistics to ensure that people cast their vote. How freely or fairly they cast is something we can never tell. In Bijoynagar one of India's easternmost airstrip and a historical one that too, polling couldn't even be held in the last LS elections along with the rest of the country. Poor weather means aircraft can't navigate so poll officials couldn't reach on time. RituRaj Konwar a photojournalist was stranded in Bijoynagar for a week when he went there to cover the election preparation this year. While the exercise is inclusive voters are far removed from the election process. Voters there Rituraj said had no idea of the names of the candidates or political parties contesting. All connectivity had collapsed. Even wireless sets were not working. There was no power to charge batteries. But voting was ensured in Bijoynagar this year though it's a bit of a farce when voters don't even know who to vote for.

The story is surprisingly no different in other parts of the region or even  the country.  Danny Dimasa is an unemployed youth in Kheroni  township on the border of Karbianglong and N C Hills. Danny says election means a few rupees and voting means casting on a certain symbol, enmasse. The symbol is decided by the village headman and determined by the kind of feast organized by the candidate. In other words the incentive is critical.

Therefore while it's been a remarkable first phase of elections with an incident free N C Hills and Karbianglong , the vote in itself has virtually lost its meaning. Till last evening grenades were taking off in Halflong, in N C Hills. Half a dozen attacks on trains passing through these districts have been reported in the run up to the polls. Security forces have been targeted. Suddenly on the day of polling the militants decided to withdraw their threat because they said they believe in the democratic process. They apparently arrived at some monetary understanding with political parties to ensure that militants will stay away for just that one day. Three helicopters and six thousand security personnel besides the routine counter insurgency forces for one parliamentary seat is a massive exercise. Neither democracy works here nor intimidation. What works is brazen nexus. A nexus in which the chief executive member of the autonomous council was recently alleged to have sponsored sixty Ak 47 rifles for a militant outfit. The member is absconding but the guns have made their way to the hills where life will soon return to a living hell.The ballot  boxes or ballot machines will move out along with the  security forces and the boys in fatigue ruling the hills will take over. For the next five years they will determine the development of the area not the candidates the people were asked to vote for.

The farce doesn't end here. Certain places in Nagaland for example Puoghoboto has recorded a 93.66 per cent turnout. Mon showed 94 per cent and Kifri an impressive 95 per cent. What happens, however, in Nagaland and a lot of hill districts of Manipur where NSCN(IM) reigns is proxy voting. At least two polling stations in Churachandpur in Manipur had a very low voter turnout but the EVM recorded a hundred per cent vote.

So the election commission's job is done. Voting to ten of the twenty four seats in insurgent North East ( a resurgent Sikkim has been forced to join this exclusive club reluctantly) have been completed without a glitch. Almost.

The ballot over the bullet as they say but cast without freedom of choice or not cast at all.

 

 
   SocialTwist Tell-a-Friend
Comments: Read | Post
Comments Post your comments
 
Posted by Rita Kaul on Apr 22, 2009
Kishalay's article 'cast a farce' made a very interesting reading.Going into the indepths of what actually the voting process is all about in these remote places of India was a stark eye opener.The very same must be taking place in other remote parts of India as well.If this continues,these places will continue being a living hell.I truly admire Kishalay's appraisal in journalism.A standing ovation to Kishalay's oeuvre.
 
Posted by Conrad Rodrigues on Apr 21, 2009
Wonderful story done by Kishalay Bhattacharjee. And it takes a lot of effort to do such kind of journalism. Indeed the situation in the north-east is very troubling and worrying.
 
 
Posted by Vikas Saxena on Apr 20, 2009
Well Done Mr. Bhattacharjee and NDTV for giving him space. And this can happen only in India. No matter what happens we are able to find a fault in it. Yes! this is how it should be, while we should have a positive outlook. Why we should say some thing is good. Our job is to find negative and we are very good at it. Rather then trying to suggest a way in which EC's efforts can be complimented to have a true democracy, we just keep saying why it can not be. Grow up, start looking at a half full glass rather then at half empty. Let's first give a thumps up to India on what she has achieve and then look forward to achieve what is remmaining rather then just keeping point out the other way round. -Vikas
 
Posted by vishvasi on Apr 19, 2009
Yeh Democracy in India is in such a condition .Its an open secret that many citizen doesnt know about the meaning of vote. Shame on our governament and leaders.U did good job Let every body know
 
Posted by Dr . Dilip Roy on Apr 18, 2009
Kudos to Krishaloy for bringing the real and authentic picture of our so called democracy and the election. I am a witness to these facts and have my close relative's account to substantive the electoral farse that has been brought to light . I thank Mr. Krishaloy for bringing the fact. I have been following your documentaries and reports for quite sometime and I admire your skill in the field.
 
Posted by Dipankar Sen Gupta on Apr 18, 2009
It till continues to make the franchise be exercised, thousands of Reang people settled in refugee camps in Tripura vote for the development or betterment (election in democratic process seems ideally so) of the land, they were displaced from, years back, Mizoram. Though the repartition has been elusive, but the democratic right means forming governance of own is realised somehow, the irony or the farce.
 
 
Post Your Comments Fields marked with * are mandatory
*Name:
E-mail:
*Comments:
  Limit 4000 characters - 4000 characters remaining
*Secure Code:
  Problem viewing this image. Click to refresh
 
 
Kindly do not post any defamatory, infringing, obscene, indecent, discriminatory or unlawful material or information. NDTV Convergence Ltd reserves the right to remove without notice any content received from users.
 
Advertisement
Advertisement
On Facebook
About Me
Kishalay Bhattacharjee is a broadcast journalist obsessed with the audio visual medium. Very opinionated that journalism is far removed from activism and he hates long bios. An Edward Murrow Fellow, Kishalay received the Ramnath Goenka Award for Journalism 2006-2007.
Latest Posts
The Untouchables: Bombay Police after 26/11
There is a story the officers of Bombay police like to tell: of brotherhood, risk and the fight against evil.
Ever-reddy
For the Reddys to be hailed as only the kings of Bellary, was galling. Their sights were set over controlling north Karnataka.
Tawang, in preparation
Tawang is in bridal makeup. Dressed for the occasion to receive their Spiritual Guru. It's a pretty picture of festivity.