»  Ear to the Ground  »   Post
Between Red and Khaki
Saturday October 24, 2009
I climbed on the rooftop, stretched my arms up in the air and my fingers began fiddling. I just required a very minuscule portion of it. "Wahan nahin," I was advised by a village boy. "Thoda do kadam aage jaayein. Haan.. bas bas.. Ab milenga."

And lo! After a good half hour of changing locations, standing on select spots and plenty of expert advise, my E71 began to breathe life again! I had some network on my phone!! Immediately, I called up my office and relayed the good news: Gadchiroli voted in spite of naxal violence.

But before I proceed further, let's trace back our journey a little.

On the 80 km route from Gadchiroli town to Regdi village, the dichotomies in the naxal-infested district couldn't be more pronounced.

Thousands of square kilometres of dense jungles, poor tribals grazing their under-fed cattle and goats, not one industry worth its name, zero mobile network and an administration that's hardly visible on the ground. But, all the way, probably the finest roads in Maharashtra. So good that the lack of development was almost forgotten.

Almost.

Some credit for these pothole-free roads, I'm told goes to BJP leader Nitin Gadkari, who during his tenure as PWD Minister in the late 1990s transformed them. So today 66 per cent of Gadchiroli's 1,688 villages are well-connected by 8,300 kms of weather enduring roads. A rare privilege - given the extent of distress in rural India - that reaches two thirds of the 10 lakh Gadchirolians. However, most villagers claim these roads were not built for them, but for the efficient movement of vehicles belonging to security personnel.

Perhaps they have a point, for these are highways that lead to nothing. Well, that is if you don't consider the two square kilometre land that has been industrialized in the entire district! Go beyond the town of Gadchiroli and you can travel for hours without any trucks or lorries whizzing past you. From the Korchi taluka bordering Chhattisgarh in the north, to Sironcha adjacent to Andhra's Karimnagar district in the south - all that exists here are a handful of paper factories, a few rice mills and some seed processing units. The district has just one railway station, 19 kms of railway 'network' and 14 civil and rural hospitals.

Log on to the district collectorate website and industrialization is given an altogether new meaning by the administration: shops that sell furniture, paints, mosaic tiles and outrageously enough confectionary and ice-cream!  

A pity, especially since the government boasts that the region is rich in minerals and can be mined for diamonds and gold. But of course - convenient and to an extent rightly so - the state blames the lack of development to the 'anti-growth policies' of naxals. After all, bridges, schools, gram panchayat offices, electricity towers have all been blown up to show who is really in control.

So what are the options here for a decent livelihood? If one wants to play it safe, then grazing cows is one. And of course, farming. If you are a rebel with a cause, then join the naxal army. If you seek risk then there is the local police force. Harsh, you would say, but this is ground reality. "We are just left with no options. There is no work here. I was not too keen on becoming a policeman given the dangers, but then I have to feed my family. There is of course no question of becoming a naxal," explains a constable.

And this is the irony. Naxals accuse the present system of governance for not alleviating the poor from their misery and of politicians being corrupt and exploiting the poor and landless. Allegations that are true and reason why Naxals launched their movement in 1967, justifying even the violence. But then Naxals do hamper growth. Try building a road and the engineer is kidnapped and then killed. Join the local police and your parents will be brutally tortured. Try setting up a small scale industry and you will have to shell out lakhs as 'protection money' to them. First to imposter Naxals who take advantage of the situation and then to the real ones.

So what about the tribals and poor villagers for whom they claim the battle is being fought?

"Every family is expected to "donate" at least one child to the cause," a villager explains to us in a remote village in the Etapalli taluka. "The police harass us because they are convinced we are Naxal sympathisers. If it is not the police then the Naxals are after us as they suspect us of being police informers. What do we do then? Where does it leave us?"

In a very unenviable and sad state of affairs. Caught between red and khaki, they feel that not only has the government not done anything for them, but even Naxals haven't been successful in solving their issues. That does not mean that Naxals don't have local support. Without it, it would be impossible for them to propagate their ideology on the ground. But for those who don't back them, they are in trouble either ways.

While reporting from Gadchiroli on Oct 13 when Maharashtra went to the polls, we all felt proud that almost 65 percent of the voters had exercised their franchise. This despite the Naxal call for a boycott and the recent killing of 17 policemen in a bloody ambush. In fact, many tribals applied coconut oil on their voting finger, so that that indelible mark we are so proud of, was removed as soon as possible. "If Naxals find out we have voted, they have warned us that fingers will be chopped off," an adivasi reveals.

Heard that before, I said to myself and I was amazed how they still managed to vote.

But I also asked: Was the impressive voter turnout here, really an occasion to celebrate? This meant the people had given a thumbs up to democracy and the present system of governance, I argued with myself. But apart from mere symbolism what will it achieve? Will it bring progress and prosperity to the people? Will they be able to live free and normal lives?

Not really. Especially when the government soon plans to launch it's biggest-ever offensive against Naxals. 15,000 Naxals and 70,000 paramilitary forces will engage in guerrilla warfare. Many will die in a bloody battle where India will fight India.

But the worst affected will be the locals, the adivasis, the villagers. And this won't alone be Gadchiroli's misfortune. The Red Corridor is spread over 20 states, across 2,000 police stations in 223 districts. Already, between 2006 and August 2009, there have been 5,800 incidents and 2,600 policemen and civilians have been killed. This is certainly our greatest internal security threat.

Surely, the Naxal onslaught has to be stopped. They are already active in Andhra Pradesh, Bihar, Chhattisgarh, Orissa, Jharkhand, Maharashtra, Madhya Pradesh, Uttar Pradesh and West Bengal. Reports suggest CPI (Maoists) have been trying to increase their influence and act in parts of Kamataka, Kerala, Tamil Nadu and Uttranchal also.

Naxals need to heed to Home Minister PC Chidambaram's call to "abjure violence" and talk.

Otherwise, there are no softer options.

Back in Regdi village, my mobile beeped. In came all my pending text messages.
One read: "Naxalites open fire on polling booth. Paramilitary forces retaliate."

In Pics: Reporting from Gadchiroli

 
   SocialTwist Tell-a-Friend
Comments: Read | Post
Comments Post your comments
 
Posted by Dr S Shankar Singh on Nov 01, 2009
As beheading of Francis Induwar indicates, Naxalism / Maoism is an Indian edition of Talibanism. Maoists are not interested in securing justice for poor, landless and adiwasis, but they are using the latter as a pawn in power game. Maoism is an ideology opposed to democracy. Maoists want to demolish democracy and in place want to instal some kind of dictatorship of a few.
 
Posted by Anil on Nov 01, 2009
A very well written article. My family suffered both because of police and naxalites. It is funny to see that even police, and naxalites themselves are victims sometimes. Now how do we resolve these problems in life? Governance structures have inherent limitations, because they are manned by people like you and me. People who can lecture on ethics for hours, and won't hesitate for a minute given a chance to loot. Look at how Maoists are playing a very constructive role in Nepal, towards the welfare of people whom they represent. They have their own politicians who want all of the world just for themselves. This is not for the first time we are seeing uprisings in the world. They have been there for ages. A hapless victim when favored by circumstances evolves into a rogue master. Look at what Jews are doing to Palestinians. As long as human beings are selfish, and greedy suffering will last. Not even god can help us, when we are driven by ego.
 
 
Posted by Bystander on Oct 31, 2009
Why our "corporate home minister" is displaying so much alacrity in sending additional troops to the tribal areas? It does not require a great deal of ingenuity to fathom it. It is for the minerals he and his masters want to command keeping in breach the very purpose of the Schedule 5 to the constitution.
 
Posted by r.r.mohanty on Oct 30, 2009
i am happy that certain people are concern about state of affiers prevelling in our country, and support the naxal uprising. But my dear, please note,uprising brought comunist to power in Bengal for over last 30years, ULFA brought AGP to power in Assam, Kishmiri brought PDP to power, Akali came to power riding on sentimate of punjabis, Shiva Sena also came to power by exploting marathi,Mayavati became C.M by virtue of dalit vote, but how far those were successful in solving popular problems? For which they came to power? Is bengal O.K. Is U.P.O.K.? My dear without a national charactor no party /group will be able to stand up to desered level. Even congress party which claims to be of national party has failed in this act, vote bank politics has brought their true color to the public.We can only hope good people will come to politics soon.
 
Posted by gyan ghosh on Oct 30, 2009
Tejas work is an eye opener,the comments above are educating,I believe the root cause of poverty,naxalism,maoism, is low price of rice Rs8/kg fixed for our agriculture produce,cost of cheapest rice is minm Rs25/kg if cultivated in 2acres land using conventional methods by paying Rs90/day minm wage stipulated by govt. from the above it is evident that the farmer(70%of our population) gets only 1/4the daily wage for the price fixed by govt to feed 5 mouths,ie Rs4/head/day that to when he gets daily work,with no Irrigation system or water he gets only 45 days of work making average per head per day income to Rs 1/ per2persons/day,much below poverty line,70% of our population lives in dire poverty to feed the total country 400% subsidised food.My point is ,abolish price fixation,subsidies,and ensure prices based on minm wage will make the major population come above poverty ,more purchasing power,growth in economy,and elliminates naxalism
 
Posted by Subroto Kar on Oct 29, 2009
So long as rich and the powerful manipulate democracy and rule of law, such uprising will continue. The day law of the land applies to everyone equally many ills like this will disappear. In 1984 thousand of sikhs were killed, recently in Gujarat thousand of muslims were killed in cold blooded....has anyone being hang so far...where is the law of the land?
 
Posted by Deboo on Oct 28, 2009
Dear Bloggers, I would request you all to please look at the 5th schedule of the Indian Constitution, and put the Government and its policies/action to its test.
 
Posted by sam on Oct 28, 2009
well written.as long as the politicians,beurecrats and police make money out of this ,the movement will stay.in fact if a bit normalcy comes the trio will make sure that the problem continues even by fake encounters.
 
Posted by Sunil on Oct 27, 2009
Very well written and insightful. Please translate and propogate! This is real journalism.
 
Posted by Prabhat Panja on Oct 27, 2009
The Govt has conveniently type cast the issues of utter lack of development in the areas of Jharkhand, Chattisgarh,AP, Orissa, Bengal etc as Naxalite problem made by so called maoists. 75 years of independence has not been able to provide sustenence to these dispossed people. These people who were living peacefully in the hinterland, in forest land have been dispossed by the unholy nexus of Politician, Bureucracy and businessman who by their machinations have made them refugees in their own land. These dispossed people have had their land and livelihood taken away by the state and made paupers in their land of their ancestors. The state is not the least bit concerned of their misery, helplessness and hopelessness in their own land. They are not Maoists. They are fighting for survival against the so called vulture of the state who do not care wether they live or die as long as their land and livelihood can be grabbed for profit. I will only do these so called maoists not have two meals a day, medicines when they fall sick,education for their children. They are the Adivasis, the original people who owned the land, the jungle but today are dispossed. The growth figures dished out by the Govt. has no meaning for them unless it feeds & clothes their children,gives them a job, education, health. Believe me no Govt is the least bit interested in their survival. I feel ashamed that after so many years of independence we have not been able to bring a smile to their lips. Every Indian has to feel for them and bring pressure on the Govt to address their development issues. The Govt has to change their policy of grabbing their land in the name of development which benifits everyone else byt the adivasis. If Jindals or TATA's or any one else are unable to builsd their factory so be it. In hindsight what Mamata bannerjee did in Singur has resulted in giving the people their livlihood. If you take away the land of the people who survive on it, you are as good as killing them, killing their very soul. Let the Govt come out with a sincere and time bound program to improve their economic condition through susteneble development. All adivasis shouls be protected from the state's anti tribal policies. Give real power to the Tribals to manage their own affairs.
 
Posted by asha nair on Oct 26, 2009
This is a extremely well written article by Tejas Mehta which has explained the situation in a naxal infested district of Maharashtra. In fact I feel that this sitauation must be similar to the situation in every naxal area of other states also. It is a sad & sorry state of affairs in such areas. Because in the end no one is gaining anything - the districts remain poor and under developed, the police excesses on suspected naxalites and informers, the retaliatory attact on police by the Naxals, the tribals, adivasis & poor villagers with no means of livelihood remaining in the same backward condition for years together. It is rightly said that naxalism is the biggest internal terrorism being faced by India today. Many people who are living in cities do not know much about the naxal problem(not being directly affected by it) and frankly do not care much. Therefore, more such live stories & reporting must be done to spread awareness about the problem. It must be realised that over a period, such internal terrorism is a threat to the economy & progress of the whole nation. Ultimately none is benefitted and ways & means must be found to put an end to it.
 
Posted by Ganesh on Oct 26, 2009
There are clearly no soft options. This has to be handled very similar to how SriLanka finished LTTE. This is not the work of local policemen. The army needs to be brought in to reclaim these areas. Cordon an area, evacuate locals, get the militants to surrender & disarm or face consequences. If it is not done now on an all India scale, militancy in Kashmir will look like child's play. This is exremely serious.
 
Posted by John LR on Oct 26, 2009
Dear Naxal Leader, If any Naxal member is reading this please inform your high command about this. Dear fellow Indians you are all part of this nation. But you named your self as Naxalite in your own country. A mother gave birth to two children. Both they educated together and bought up. With the inflence of few people one child is having revelutionary ideas and views. It is not bad to think any type of ideas. But those thoughts and ideas has to benifit to each and every one in the society. Here I am not pointing one from tribal area and another from capital. There are plenty of people who is suffering from poverty in the capital. Help humanity. A organisation is unable to understand human daily needs there is no use of following any type of principles. So far what are the achievements the Organisation really made it? It is not a critisium it is a fact and truth. In common people's mind if you say I am from this organisation either they will run away from you or they will inform authorities about the person. WHY? That means the common man is not beleaving you and the organisation principles. Please take example.If you like it or just ignore it. The Mao is born in China. The world knows about it.In China the party developed the nation. Irrespective and differences between the caders ideas and views. They worked together they build up the nation. Please just think about it. If your organisation is having any faith on our common man please help them. Tomorrow they are your voice and future. And at the same time try to eleminate bad people from the society. But not to take the law in your hand. I am saying that forget your organisation principles. You follow it but not to impliment by force on others. If they want to follow ask them to welcome. If not just ignore them. No one in the world they are perfect. We have religions. Later we divided Casts in that types of Groups. This is the main reason we are facing this problem. May ask you a simple question but it is very difficult for you to answer. In your organisation also do you have SC, ST, BC A, B, C, D groups along with religion please question your self? If your organisation is having this type of system it will collapse. So if you want to bring any change in our nation first follow and try to eliminate this SC, ST, BC and so on groups. And try to remove the bad elements. From the deep roots. As your organisation says that "They want to help the tribes ADIVASI" Even Rahul Gandhi also trying to do the same. SO? Who is correct? And being a Indian I can say our improvement is nothing. Your organisation they say not to poll your vote. But Party they say you give me vote I will give 500 Rupees Note. To keep alive in my place I must think it 100 times if I take that 500 Rupees note and vote I can servive with my family 20 days. As per government policy there are lot of promises but it never be fulfilled we know that. They purchased my family two votes with 1000 Rupees for 5 years . WE don't have any right to ask why you are not doing any thing for us. Please Dear Naxal Leader step in to the society and try to understand your own people what are all the problems and solve it like ROBINSON. He too was named as bad man. But he did good thing for those people who are in real problems. But please not to damage your own nations property. With those distruction your dreams about poor people are all dristrubing. We work for daily wages. With those band's our daily meal was removed from our mouth. We are not alone there are elder people and small children. I beleave you can under stand if you don't have food and water for a day or two. For sake of food if we go out side we get lati from out side. You must under stand the nation sir. If you are unable to come out and solve the problems HOW CAN YOU RULE THIS NATION IF YOU GET A CHANGE? The mother will over look what her son did for others. YOU ARE A RESPECTED INDIAN AND PART OF OUR SOCIETY.
 
Posted by Ketki P on Oct 24, 2009
The blog is an amazing insight of the process of election and voting by the most vulnerable class of the society. Although in the interest of the general public, can this blog be published in hindi and marathi as well. This is the need of time and people need to be aware of the facts.
 
 
Post Your Comments Fields marked with * are mandatory
*Name:
E-mail:
*Comments:
  Limit 4000 characters - 4000 characters remaining
*Secure Code:
  Problem viewing this image. Click to refresh
 
 
Kindly do not post any defamatory, infringing, obscene, indecent, discriminatory or unlawful material or information. NDTV Convergence Ltd reserves the right to remove without notice any content received from users.
 
Advertisement
Advertisement
On Facebook
About Me
Tejas Mehta is a Mumbai-based journalist with NDTV 24X7. He is a daily news reporter who enjoys being in the field. Now a broadcast journalist, he was earlier with the print media.
Latest Posts
The Untouchables: Bombay Police after 26/11
There is a story the officers of Bombay police like to tell: of brotherhood, risk and the fight against evil.
Ever-reddy
For the Reddys to be hailed as only the kings of Bellary, was galling. Their sights were set over controlling north Karnataka.
Tawang, in preparation
Tawang is in bridal makeup. Dressed for the occasion to receive their Spiritual Guru. It's a pretty picture of festivity.