»  Arms and the Men  »   Post
Double standards of the West
Monday June 1, 2009 , New Delhi, India

If ever there was a proof needed about the double standards applied by the Western nations in dealing with Asia and Africa, there is no better example than their reaction to the developments in Sri Lanka over the last fortnight.

Here's a nation that secured a hard-earned military victory over what was unarguably the world's most dreaded and ruthless terrorist group--the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam or LTTE. Banned in 26 countries across the globe, the Tamil Tigers, as the LTTE was also known, had a powerful naval arm, a rudimentary air wing and at least 25,000 infantry fighters backed like a conventional army with 155 mm artillery guns, multi-barrel rocket launchers, Universal machine guns and claymore mines among other small arms.

This was the outfit that gave the world the suicide vest and suicide belt that were responsible for the assassination of at least one President and a former Prime Minister across two nations, this was the group that killed and wounded at least 70,000 people over a quarter century; here was a group who's writ ran large over one-third of a sovereign nation. And to top it all, the LTTE had kept over 250,000 innocent, hapless Tamil civilians--women, children, the young and the old--hostage for over two years and mercilessly used them as an insurance against the advancing Sri Lankan army.

If ever there was a ripe case for a well-planned and executed military operation, here it was in Sri Lanka. President Mahinda Rajapakse and his team went about prosecuting what, by all accounts, was a legitimate war. But the world, the Western world went into an overdrive to stop Colombo. Norway, Sweden, UK and to a lesser extent the United States put pressure on Sri Lanka by various means. Some threatened to move a resolution in the UN, others lobbied to prevent a bailout package mooted by the International Monetary Fund for the war-ravaged country. Now, many have called for war crime investigations into the conduct of the Sri Lankan military.

Had it not been for countries like Russia, China and to an extent India, Sri Lanka would have suffered grievously at the hands of the so-called liberal lobby, ably aided and abetted by the 'bleeding-heart' liberals among the western media who think they are the judge, jury and executors when it comes to dealing with Asian and African nations. All of them had tried to stop the war in Sri Lanka, ostensibly to safeguard the civilians but in reality the efforts were directed at rescuing LTTE chief Vellupillai Prabhakaran and his top associates.

The simple and bitter truth is: the Western world has not been able to digest the fact that a small, underdeveloped nation like Sri Lanka has managed to defeat a terrorist group, a feat that they have not managed despite deploying huge resources and manpower across the globe.

For years, the US and the NATO countries have been trying to vanquish the Al Qaeda and the Taliban, without much success. In the past decade, the US and other western militaries, operating in Iraq and Afghanistan to take just two recent examples, have killed and maimed scores of civilians. But except for cursory apologies, none of these nations or the defenders of human rights operating from the safe havens of western capitals have bothered to even acknowledge their gross mistakes.

So why is it that a small nation's victory over terrorism "fit to be tried for war crimes," but a big bully's (like the US) blatant violation of human rights is part of a "necessary war on terrorism?" Why didn't any one of these defenders of human rights put pressure on the LTTE when it was taking hundreds of thousands of civilians along with it as it retreated during the war?

If ever there is a clear case of the western nations' hypocrisy, it is demonstrable here in India's backyard, in Sri Lanka. Let Washington and London and Bonn and Ottawa first look at their own conduct before trying to prosecute a small country for doing what any sovereign nation has a right to do.

(The author, NDTV's Defence Editor, reported the war in Sri Lanka from the conflict zone for the past six months)

 
   SocialTwist Tell-a-Friend
Comments: Read | Post
Tags: LTE , Sri Lanka , West

Comments Post your comments
Showing 61-80 of 142
 
Posted by jbenedict on Jun 02, 2009
Nearly 20,000 innocent Tamils have been massacred by Rajapakse and his brothers in the so called no fire zone and you would like to call this a legitimate war! Your moral compass is so out of kilter I am beginning to wonder if you are on the planet as the rest of us. If you had cared to spend 5 minutes talking to any member of the Sri Lankan Tamil community which has and continues to suffer untold racial prejudice at the hands of the Singhalese chauvinist regime you would have retitled your article - - "A mass genocide in India's backyard". You must understand that 250,000 Tamils chose to live under LTTE rule rather than suffer at the hands of the racist Sri Lankan government. It is a well documented fact that the discrimination against Sri Lankan Tamils by majority Singhalese started well before the birth of LTTE. You have conveniently ignored the ethnic riots in 1958, 1977 & 1983 when Singalese thugs killed hundreds and thousands of innocent Tamils. Does your 70,000 include these casualities? You do not have to be rocket scientist to work out that LTTE was a product of racial oppression. Thanks to USA, UK and other western countries that have protested against this mass murder and shown that humanity is alive and well. Shame on China and India for supporting the genocide by this barbaric regime
 
Posted by Akshay on Jun 02, 2009
Agreed!Westerners have their own way of looking into things
 
 
Posted by Chandima on Jun 02, 2009
Mr. Nitin, you are a true friend of Sri Lanka. I saw one of your documetries of Sri Lankan war. It was amazing and you are one of the few jurnalist who report the true story about sri lanka. I would like to Thank you on behalf of every Sri Lankan.
 
Posted by JAME$ on Jun 02, 2009
HI , I THINK IT WAS TRUE TO DAY, WEST DID TRY 2 HELP TO LTTE , REASONS COULD BE TILL NOW THE THOUGHT LTTE AS TERRORIST GROUP,DISPORA GROUPS EFFORTS TO BRING HISTROIC TRUE ABOUT EELAM, - TWO NATION , ONE ISLAND - WEST UNDERSTOOD LATE ABOUT THE LTTE , LTTE ITSELF IS NEW TO EELAM CONCEPT , WHICH DATES BACK TO 15 AD AND WEST WANTED TO KEEP REGIONAL POWER "ON" SOME DAY LIKE INDIA,CHINE,RUSSIA,& PAK DID!!! WEST COULD MAKE MONEY OUT OF KILLING FEW FOR MULTIMILLON $ , U SEE THIS IS REALLITY AT THE END MY FELLOW TAMIL ARE EXPERMENTAL GUNNIE PIG , EELAM IS SLUATTER HOUSE FOR SLGOV,INDIA,CHINE,PAK STOP PLIZ ALL U GM !! WE IN WORLD LIVE SIDE BY SIDE TO CALL OURSELF AS HUMAN BEIN NOT ANIMALS HELP ME GOD-HELP TAMILS & LTTE BROTHERS -JAME$
 
Posted by Ravi Kumar on Jun 02, 2009
I think the West's reaction is primarily due to the Tamil Diaspora's lobbying. There are reports which say that the Tamil issue in Srilanka had helped some of the Tamils in settling down in countries like US, France and UK.
 
Posted by vikramaditya on Jun 02, 2009
I agree to watever said. US, UK and other supporting nations have always undervalued the damage done by these terrorists group until the same happened to them. In spite of being victim of the terror forces, they still have not realized how importance of acting jointly with other supporting nations. not so strangely "these" nations have not made any attempt of learning lessons from the mistakes and strategies deployed by the terror affected nations (india, srilanka etc). not so fair world.
 
Posted by Dharmaraj.J on Jun 02, 2009
By writing in english one should not forget history. Before Srilanka was ruled by British it was country of three nations, Jaffna was not ruled by Sinahalese. It was ruled by a Tamil Kinek. Similarly the Kandy part. The thought of independent Elam was grown because of Treatinting Tamilians as Third class citizens. In the name of Defeating LTTE the Srilankan Government has commited Racial Genocide by Killing more than Lakh of civilians. which The west has rightly pointed out. Rajapakshe has to be tried for war crimes and executed accordingly for this crime against humanity. North of India doe not represnt the whole India. Let The North not dictate the foreign policy. No one has the foresight or vision to have a long term foreign policy. India is making ablunder by looking at shor term gains . ONly time will tell how the Srilankans will join China and humilate INdia.
 
Posted by dennis on Jun 02, 2009
Hello! Very interesting, the media here really doesn't go into much detail about LTE,Sri Lanka, West. All we hear now is Obama this and Obama that and the economy. I would really like to hear more about global issue's more, it seems we don't anymore, Wars are horrable I am 63 years and have seen enough! What should take place is the leaders that really want to fight get in a big ring and fight each other until one is left standing, to much hatred in this country and it appears everywhere in th world. I am seriously going to do some research on Sri Lanka and see if I can find out culture, religion, history, etc,. I appreciate your article. Dennis
 
Posted by Cedric Andrade on Jun 02, 2009
When civilians are killed by western troops in Iraq, Afghanistan or even in Central America, they are termed as terrorists or it is often claimed that the soldiers fired in self defence. However, when civilians being used as human shields by hard core terrorists, are killed in Sri Lanka, by an army fighting a legitimate war in it's own homeland, the west suddenly talks about "war crimes" & "human rights". It is unfortunate that the so-called upholders of freedom & human rights (the west) has a set of standards that they apply at will only to Asian & African countries. As for themselves, the less said, the better.
 
Posted by Kamal on Jun 02, 2009
This report is perfect one. I beleive this type of report must get more coverage in print & electronic media.
 
Posted by s.sunder on Jun 02, 2009
I fully agree with the incisive analysis of Nitin Gokhale regarding the double standards of the West in dealing with the Sri Lankan issue. The Western countries have played a dubious role in allowing the LTTE to mobilise funds in UK, USA, France etc. for their terrorist activities. Even now the Sri Lankan Tamil diaspora is freely allowed to carry on propaganda in favour of the banned LTTE organisation. The proposed resolution in the UN indicting Sri Lanka for human rights violations could not be carried out thanks to the Asian countries including India and China. Instead of focusing on so-called human rights violations, the entire focus should now be on rehabilitating and resettling the Tamil refugees and developing the shattered economy of Sri Lanka. The Sri Lankan govt. should sincerely take steps for devolution of powers to the Tamil provinces so that legitimate grievances of the Tamils are taken care of. Sunder
 
Posted by Rajiv De Sylva on Jun 02, 2009
Dear Nitin, Thank you for your honest and the correct story. People like you, who tell the story the way it is, are hard to find. Sadly we havent seen such an article by even a Sri Lankan.
 
Posted by subha on Jun 02, 2009
Don't just quote the statistics provided by the Srilankan Government when you want to be a responsible and reasonable journalist. If you say because of LTTE the srilankan tamils are suffered for the past 30 years, then what is the next step...Are we going to get few ships to send the lakhs and lakhs of refugee's in India, back to the peaceful nation? As for as your channel is concerned Srilankan government did everything right, i have no problems with eradicating any terrorist organisation including LTTE, but killing common man by shelling can not be justified, if they are clean why they are not allowing the people to live freely and why no one allowed to visit them...please don't write and talk from Colombo....its like me talking about kashmir conflict sitting in Kanyakumari without understanding the complexity of the problem and the people's feeling...that is what exactly the media is doing now....instead of reporting from colombo you can very well do it from Delhi... .
 
Posted by Pankaj Dwivedi on Jun 02, 2009
I fully agree. As they all the laws are meant for those who are morally-correct and defenceless. We have to find ways to curb this Big Brother attitude of the West while exploring ways to improve the value of human life in entire South Asia.
 
Posted by Jayabalaji M D on Jun 02, 2009
What about journalists and aid organisations are not allowed inside SL? Do they have anything to hide? What abt the TIMES article which accuse SL govt of 20 thousand civilian killings in a day with photo proof. Do you call this victory?Truth never dies may be little late to wake up.
 
Posted by mawella on Jun 02, 2009
Nitin, simply describes, what happend and to be happened.We know what hardships experinced, some times no words to explain. The LTTE ruined the country, culture, heritage and social standards for last 30 years. LTTE never wanted for settle problem by talking but by guns. we relieved now. We can walk peacefully in Jaffna, Colombo or Batticoloa.
 
Posted by Harkirat on Jun 02, 2009
Hi, The human life loss cannot be brought back .this was a tremendous effort by shrilankan govt. to erase the terrorism from its soil. the same approach should also be taken by Pakistan govt. the motto of both the militant group may be different , but the loss of innocent life of citizen is what worries everyone. H.S.Jabbal
 
Posted by mayukh on Jun 02, 2009
Sri Lanka defended it's sovereignty within its OWN boundaries, any commentary by a second country is gross interference. Only India could be concerned in apprehension of a refugee problem. Rest of the world has nothing to do in the affairs of a sovereign nation defending its territorial integrity.
 
Posted by Vikram V on Jun 02, 2009
I completely agree with Nitin that the attitude of the west in undermining the lankan governments' victory over the LTTE is hypocrisy. However i disagree with 2 statements made by Nitin in interpreting the reaction from the West. Firstly, I think Nitin's assesment that the efforts of the western nations were directed towards rescuing LTTE [specifically Prabhakaran] need more explanation. It would be nice if Nitin, supports this claim with more evidence and reasoning. The second statement that the Western world is not able to digest the fact that an underdeveloped country like Srilanka has vanquished a global terrorist group like the LTTE seems incorrect. Since everyone realizes that the nature of the enemy confronted is starkly different. I am sure there are various reasons as to why the LTTE were cornered the way they were. Hence I think it is stretching it a bit too far to assume that the western nations are unable to digest Srilanka's victory, unless Nitin cites evidence/reasoning that proves otherwise. In conclusion , I agree that the west is being hypocritical when it points its finger towards Srilanka. But at the end of the day someone needs to count the bodies and justify the end result. Do the means justify the end? It is still a question that needs answers even though the question comes from someone who does not have the right to take the moral high ground.
 
Posted by parmita borah on Jun 02, 2009
Very insightful read.The western nations' hypocrisy and especially their habit of playing GOD in developing nations is no secret anymore. They just want the Asian, African and Middle Eastern countries to fight among themselves so that these countries resort to the west for weapons and get dumped with World Bank debts! All they care about the rest of the world is probably just a "Piece of the Action"
 
 
Post Your Comments Fields marked with * are mandatory
*Name:
E-mail:
*Comments:
  Limit 4000 characters - 4000 characters remaining
*Secure Code:
  Problem viewing this image. Click to refresh
 
 
Kindly do not post any defamatory, infringing, obscene, indecent, discriminatory or unlawful material or information. NDTV Convergence Ltd reserves the right to remove without notice any content received from users.
 
Advertisement
Advertisement
On Facebook
About Me
A student of conflicts, insurgencies and wars, Nitin Gokhale has spent 26 years reporting on military and militants from various hostile fields like India's north-east, Kashmir valley, the Kargil war, China and Sri Lanka, among others. He's currently NDTV's Defence and Strategic Affairs Editor.
Latest Posts
The Untouchables: Bombay Police after 26/11
There is a story the officers of Bombay police like to tell: of brotherhood, risk and the fight against evil.
Ever-reddy
For the Reddys to be hailed as only the kings of Bellary, was galling. Their sights were set over controlling north Karnataka.
Tawang, in preparation
Tawang is in bridal makeup. Dressed for the occasion to receive their Spiritual Guru. It's a pretty picture of festivity.