»  Arms and the Men  »   Post
Double standards of the West
Monday June 1, 2009 , New Delhi, India

If ever there was a proof needed about the double standards applied by the Western nations in dealing with Asia and Africa, there is no better example than their reaction to the developments in Sri Lanka over the last fortnight.

Here's a nation that secured a hard-earned military victory over what was unarguably the world's most dreaded and ruthless terrorist group--the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam or LTTE. Banned in 26 countries across the globe, the Tamil Tigers, as the LTTE was also known, had a powerful naval arm, a rudimentary air wing and at least 25,000 infantry fighters backed like a conventional army with 155 mm artillery guns, multi-barrel rocket launchers, Universal machine guns and claymore mines among other small arms.

This was the outfit that gave the world the suicide vest and suicide belt that were responsible for the assassination of at least one President and a former Prime Minister across two nations, this was the group that killed and wounded at least 70,000 people over a quarter century; here was a group who's writ ran large over one-third of a sovereign nation. And to top it all, the LTTE had kept over 250,000 innocent, hapless Tamil civilians--women, children, the young and the old--hostage for over two years and mercilessly used them as an insurance against the advancing Sri Lankan army.

If ever there was a ripe case for a well-planned and executed military operation, here it was in Sri Lanka. President Mahinda Rajapakse and his team went about prosecuting what, by all accounts, was a legitimate war. But the world, the Western world went into an overdrive to stop Colombo. Norway, Sweden, UK and to a lesser extent the United States put pressure on Sri Lanka by various means. Some threatened to move a resolution in the UN, others lobbied to prevent a bailout package mooted by the International Monetary Fund for the war-ravaged country. Now, many have called for war crime investigations into the conduct of the Sri Lankan military.

Had it not been for countries like Russia, China and to an extent India, Sri Lanka would have suffered grievously at the hands of the so-called liberal lobby, ably aided and abetted by the 'bleeding-heart' liberals among the western media who think they are the judge, jury and executors when it comes to dealing with Asian and African nations. All of them had tried to stop the war in Sri Lanka, ostensibly to safeguard the civilians but in reality the efforts were directed at rescuing LTTE chief Vellupillai Prabhakaran and his top associates.

The simple and bitter truth is: the Western world has not been able to digest the fact that a small, underdeveloped nation like Sri Lanka has managed to defeat a terrorist group, a feat that they have not managed despite deploying huge resources and manpower across the globe.

For years, the US and the NATO countries have been trying to vanquish the Al Qaeda and the Taliban, without much success. In the past decade, the US and other western militaries, operating in Iraq and Afghanistan to take just two recent examples, have killed and maimed scores of civilians. But except for cursory apologies, none of these nations or the defenders of human rights operating from the safe havens of western capitals have bothered to even acknowledge their gross mistakes.

So why is it that a small nation's victory over terrorism "fit to be tried for war crimes," but a big bully's (like the US) blatant violation of human rights is part of a "necessary war on terrorism?" Why didn't any one of these defenders of human rights put pressure on the LTTE when it was taking hundreds of thousands of civilians along with it as it retreated during the war?

If ever there is a clear case of the western nations' hypocrisy, it is demonstrable here in India's backyard, in Sri Lanka. Let Washington and London and Bonn and Ottawa first look at their own conduct before trying to prosecute a small country for doing what any sovereign nation has a right to do.

(The author, NDTV's Defence Editor, reported the war in Sri Lanka from the conflict zone for the past six months)

 
   SocialTwist Tell-a-Friend
Comments: Read | Post
Tags: LTE , Sri Lanka , West

Comments Post your comments
Showing 41-60 of 142
 
Posted by Murugan on Jun 02, 2009
I am begining to wonder why we are all having 2 eyes. Please write an article which is acceptable by the people who has gone through the hell so called liberation war & Nitin you look to me as if you have only one eye.
 
Posted by joji on Jun 02, 2009
LTTE lost the day IPKF was sent to srilanka. That is when LTTE lost India. Lots of indian soldiers were killed. Rajiv Gandhi's assasination sealed the fate of LTTE. indian support the right of tamils to a peaceful and rightful place in srilanka but terrorists like Prabhakaran have to meet this fate for having killed so many innocents.
 
 
Posted by Akshay on Jun 02, 2009
Tell us something new about the western nations. This has been their policy since ages. For them human rights are only limited to South Asia and Sub-Saharan Africa. Also their definition of human rights doesn't include the thousands innocent lives lost in the past 25 years and the amount of suffering seen. Only when it comes to eradicating people like Prabhakaran do they think of human rights and start preaching about human welfare and " VETO ". I agree with Mr. Gokhale on this issue and appreciate his efforts to bring out the true picture about the west and their definition of human rights. I hope that such articles get better public attention. This will awaken the public against the dual policies of the west.
 
Posted by Nathan on Jun 02, 2009
Sri Lanka is a country where there is virtual on journalists and they were barred from the War Zone and further Independent journalists including the noted Editor of Sunday Leader Lasantha Wikramatunga who even wrote a postumous and over 20 journalists have been killed or jailed including Iqbal Atris and several others have fled the country and I find Nitin only echoing the offical line as he like other journalists have not been allowed to independent reporting or travel in the War zone independently.Further Jouralists both Sri Lankan Tamil like the Uthayan and Channel 4 were arrested when there reports were not pro government.LTTE is banned in the EEC and the United States and Canada .The West in not supporting the LTTE .Tamils lived in the LTTE controlled areas in the north in Kilinochi the rebel capital and area of the North for more than 25 years before it was captured in the current offensive by the Sri Lankan Army.Sri Lanka has detained the entire 300000 Tamils in internment camps with no access for aid agencies and media except on conducted tours and even those wish to move out are not being allowed to move out.Tamils do not see the Sri Lankan Army which is 99% sinhalese which virtually no minority recruitment as libertors and the War was opposed by almost the Entire Tamil World including in Tamil Nadu atleast publicly. Sri Lanka bombed hospitals repeatedly and the fact that civilians were attacked brutally in the No fire zone killing over 20000 thousand made the World protest countries protest and if UN security General Ban Ki-moon wants that aid agencies be given access to those detained these are justified demands .Further Sri Lanka barred the Media from the War zone to conceal the brutal killing and it opposes an independent inquiry to conceal the massacre.China backs World's brutal regimes including Myamnar,North Korea,Sudan and now Sri Lanka and China's own human rights is terrible in Tibet and the rest of China and hence backs any country which has poor human Record similar is the case with Russia.
 
Posted by Ashutosh on Jun 02, 2009
This just shows how North Indians don't care a monkey's tail when it comes to the plights of South Indians. They live in a world of their own. If Gujaratis are persecuted in Indonesia, they have a sympathetic view. If Tamils are persecuted in Srilanka, they support it. LTTE is a terroris group, without doubt. But this article smells of lack of compassion to the Tamils in Srilanka and seem to suggest that their persecution to get rid of LTTE was acceptable.
 
Posted by Srini on Jun 02, 2009
it is a great article from NDTV. The War without any journalists and the milirary with 100% percent majority people (Singhalesh) to kill thousands of minority tamils with no accountability. Even today UN says no body knows how many innocent people killed by this War. If West is trying to save LTTE by asking govenment for ceasefire and what India did few months back in Gazza strip when Isreal army was taking action against Hamaas rockets.. Isn't this hypocrisy or double standards?
 
Posted by Bimal Majumdar on Jun 02, 2009
The Western countries run a huge industry of manufacturing weapons. Hence, they want to keep up their 'market' by keeping up conflicts. The reason for Western double standard is this simple fact. Most unethical, of course, but that is how they are!
 
Posted by Rajan on Jun 02, 2009
Sri Lankans should understand that Brutality and deadliest activities was first initiated by Sri Lankan armed forces in a highly unacceptable manner. However claims that terrorism has been wiped out from Sri Lanka,the Goverment agencies should be put under stict scanner and trailed by international agency for gross violation of Human rights. For those who are pleading innocense that their action was only against terrorist and it was well palnned , Then why not international agencies (even though not media )were not allowed to monitor their activities ? This itself shows how much of truth is present in their claim...
 
Posted by GERSHOM CHELLIAH on Jun 02, 2009
DEARLY BELOVED, INNUMERABLE INNOCENT PEOPLE WERE ELIMINATED IN THE NAME OF FIGHTING TERROR, BY NONE OTHER THAN THE GUARDIAN GOVERNMENT OF SRI LANKA. THE DEAD HAD LOST THEIR RIGHT TO LIVE THANKS TO THE MEASURES TAKEN BY THE LIFE SAVING GOVERNMENT. THE LIVING MEN AND WOMEN MAY PRAISE THE GOVERNMENT FOR KEEPING THEM ALIVE.BUT REMEMBER,IF THE SAME HISTORY REPEATS ITSELF IN OUR OWN FAMILY OR OUR OWN SOCEITY WHERE WILL WE GO AND HOW WILL WE CRY? LET US THINK TWICE BEFORE WE WRITE ONCE.GOD BE MERCIFUL TO THE INNOCENT VICTIMS.
 
Posted by JBENEDICT on Jun 02, 2009
Please do not let your prejudice against the West cloud your judgement. Rajapakse and his sadistic regime have carried out a war without any witnesses. If SL govt has carried out a legitimate war, as Mr Gokhale would like us to believe, why doesn't it let the journalists and aid workers into the devastated region so they can see it for themselves rather than report what the SL govt wants? Why beat up/eliminate journalists (another brave one got beaten up a couple of days ago)who challenge its version of events? Mr Nagarajan - A noble prize for peace for Mr Rajapakse? I think it should go hand in hand with the title "Butcher of Wanni".
 
Posted by S R Iyer on Jun 02, 2009
Dear Nitin I agree with your article only partially While we don't debate about the terrorist activities of the so called LTTE, Let us remember what had happened during 1977 to 1983 and a massacre to an unbelievable extent. Singhalese chauvinists and buddhists monks took control of parliament and passed laws and resettlements which were making tamils unliveable in northern/eastern parts of SL. Where were you when those children/aged/hapeless victims suffered at the hands of SL army for no fault of them. You should have put the things in correc perspective. Just imagine, had there not been organisations like LTTE, TELO, etc., the tamil community would have been buried long back in the srilankan jungles. Every liberation movement in the world is always viewed as TERRORISM by their own country. Looking back, Subhash chandra bose, VOC, and Gandhiji were termed as terrorists by Britishers in those days. As we got freedom, we treat them as immortals. The political wing of LTTE should have worked a compromise formulae, devolution of powers and a self governance and that would have brought a heaven for all the parties concerned. Unfortunately it did not happened. The war is yet to be over in SL, because, if the SL government is not giving the genuine and deserved freedom to the tamil population, I fear the worst, restlessness and fighting will begin again. Because, it is a "movement". Hope you highlight this in your article. Why the relief officials are banned from entering the NFZ till now. Why are you not highlighting. Public memory is poor and people will forget this chapter as they will be busy with other problems and perquisites. Already Chinese, Pakistanis are investing in SL in a big way. Do you at least think this is against the security interests of India. thanks for your views..but some facts are missing regards S R IYER
 
Posted by viny on Jun 02, 2009
If the US/UK hit a civilian target in Iraq/Afghanistan, they are chastised left and right, their own forces are called war criminals. The major difference here is Iraq/Afghanistan is out of their soverign limits. What we see in SriLanka is a killing of its own citizens as collateral damage. I am not defending the LTTE or Prabharan in this, What SriLanka did was right, but there should have been more regard for civilians, its own citizens, those same people whom the President of the country took oath to serve and protect. Instead he chose to bomb a ethnic group of civilians for the protections of others. THAT IS THE PROBLEM. When you are a president, you are a president of everyone, when the risk is that many civilian lives you look for an alternative plan. If there is no alternative plan you wait but you protect the civilians
 
Posted by sitanshu on Jun 02, 2009
I partially agree with the above article. Infact the above article projects how west which is masking the role of demolishers of terrorist organisation is a fake. but in contrast i opine that it was easy for srilanka to send such a huge army in its owm terrain while westerns have to fight a war on alien land with alien terrain. Thus it should be a slow process. so lets hope that we will be able to uproot terrorism completely.
 
Posted by R.Kannan on Jun 02, 2009
Good article. The US & Pak army are fighting a much weaker force in the Taliban as compared to the LTTE. The main reason why this war has been going on for so long is support to the Taliban by Pak army. Pak army claims victory but nobody believes their claims especially as they are not prepared to show visible signs of victory. What SL has done has been to show up the hypocricy of the western world. They have issues related to human rights when terrorists are defeated but another standard when innocent human beings are killed by terrorists. They have no problems in giving aid worth billions to Pakistan which uses them to create terror armies as well as for nuclear weapons proliferation but if victims of terror, like SL or India, take action , all these scoundrels rush in claiming human rights abuse.
 
Posted by Periyanayagam on Jun 02, 2009
The argument of Mr. Nitin Gokhale is merely one aspect of looking at things. I very well understand his arguments as he was a student of conflicts, insurgencies and wars that he has spent twenty six years reporting on military and militants from various hostile fields like India's north-east, Kashmir valley, the Kargil war, China and Sri Lanka, among others (Source: NDTV on 2nd June 2009). It is purely a military aspects of looking at things. But a matured intelligent and a humanitarian person will consider the overall aspects of the war before concluding the judgment. (Like: Government and its functioning; Citizens and their rights%u2026). And if at all there are problems and conflicts between them, one should consider the causes that originated of the conflict between them; Of-course, %u2018the means should always justify the end%u2019 and it is the moral law. Thank you, periyanayagamhec@rediffmail.com Cameroon.
 
Posted by P.N.Nagarajan on Jun 02, 2009
At long last, an article that puts the Lankan Internal wall in the righr perspective. If the US and the west can get away with their Drone attacks and the mess in erswhile Yugoslavia, Iraq and Afghanistan, Northern Ireland, not to speak of Latin America,in the name of terror, the Lankan Government is to be commended for destroying the deadliest terror outfit in the world. As the writer has said it is too much for the patronising west to stomach the success of a small black country. Stretching a point, if Kissinger can get the Nobel Prize for Vietnam, and gandhi not even being nominated, Rajapakse should be given the Nobel Prize for Peace as the first state leader to have destroyed a terrorist organization
 
Posted by Kane on Jun 02, 2009
Well This is a well written article that does indeed show the blatant double standards of western nationals. Here I must add the UK's double standard is even more glaring, as the Liberals are after the US government very strongly. But the UK that has cynically gone into the Iraq and Afganistan and yet not a tweet from its press against these misadventures. By the way, there is a small mistake. Bonn is not longer a western capital. Its Berlin now for unified Germany for quite some time
 
Posted by raja on Jun 02, 2009
Typical Aryan outlook, what else tamils can expect from these nomadic tribes from central asia. I can see indepedent tamil state very soon in Indian ocean to fkup Aryans big time
 
Posted by Atul on Jun 02, 2009
Very rightly commented. West has crowned itself as the saviour of the world and behaves as the big brother for the entire world. Look at the war crimes committed by NATO forces and US and allies in Afganistan and Iraq. No one questions them and even UN -the toothless world body plays in their hands. Every war has has its pros and cons. No doubt,there would have been some excesses committed in its fight with LTTE. However the manner in which Srilanka decided to take on defeat the LTTE, it should be commended for its courage and the planning. Remember Srilanka has been fighting the war for over 25 years. We too have suffered at the hands of LTTE when our promising leader, Rajiv Gandhi is killed at their hands. India should learn lessons and apply these means to counter separatists movements in various regions across the country specially the maoists. India worries about the world reaction and does not have the courage to anger the world community at large.
 
Posted by Aashit Shah on Jun 02, 2009
This is one of the first articles which gives the right perspective of the final assault on the LTTE. The militant organisation rightly deserved the treatment meted out to it after years of ruthless killings. I also salute the president of Sri Lanka whose patriotism and selfless dedication has liberated the oppressed masses of his motherland from this scourge. My heart also bleeds for those tamil citizens who were used as scapegoats to the very bitter end by their so called liberators. If the LTTE had any love and care for these people they should have surrendered when they knew that defeat was imminent rather than using these hapless civilians as cannon fodder and trying to broker a ceasefire by fooling the international community.
 
 
Post Your Comments Fields marked with * are mandatory
*Name:
E-mail:
*Comments:
  Limit 4000 characters - 4000 characters remaining
*Secure Code:
  Problem viewing this image. Click to refresh
 
 
Kindly do not post any defamatory, infringing, obscene, indecent, discriminatory or unlawful material or information. NDTV Convergence Ltd reserves the right to remove without notice any content received from users.
 
Advertisement
Advertisement
On Facebook
About Me
A student of conflicts, insurgencies and wars, Nitin Gokhale has spent 26 years reporting on military and militants from various hostile fields like India's north-east, Kashmir valley, the Kargil war, China and Sri Lanka, among others. He's currently NDTV's Defence and Strategic Affairs Editor.
Latest Posts
The Untouchables: Bombay Police after 26/11
There is a story the officers of Bombay police like to tell: of brotherhood, risk and the fight against evil.
Ever-reddy
For the Reddys to be hailed as only the kings of Bellary, was galling. Their sights were set over controlling north Karnataka.
Tawang, in preparation
Tawang is in bridal makeup. Dressed for the occasion to receive their Spiritual Guru. It's a pretty picture of festivity.