| |
Newsletter 
  RSS
NDTV.com
Updated: November 21, 2009 22:34 IST
   What's New:   Classifieds   |   Auto   |   Jobs   |   Tutoring US only NDTV GURUJI NDTV Search
NDTV Print Story Story Video Story Images Story Comments Message Board
Rate the Story
NDTV Active
To read the biggest stories of the day on your mobile, type mobile.ndtv.com on your phone browser.
As it happens:
Most Watched Videos
NDTV
My best romantic song ever: Kareena
NDTV
I stand by my love: Kareena
NDTV
Farah picks Akshay over SRK
NDTV
Ash taken aback by Paa
NDTV
Akshay, Suneil, Paresh on De Dana Dan
Poll Center
Did US corporate interest help in the passage of N-deal?
Yes
No
Can't say
Forums
The signing of the N-deal bill will herald a new era in Indo-US relations.
User Name Password
New User ? Sign In
It appears that the CPI(M) has softened its rhetoric towards the stand-off with the government.

The CPI(M) General Secretary Prakash Karat said at a press conference on Thursday that the Left did not want the crisis over the Indo-US nuclear deal to affect the government.

At the same time the CPI(M) made it clear that it is still opposed to the nuclear deal being operationalised and the government's future depended on the government itself.

Earlier, the Central Committee of the CPI(M) had endorsed the party Politburo's opposition to the Indo-US nuclear deal and authorised it to do whatever it can to block the deal.

This means if the politburo decides on withdrawing support in the event of the government going ahead with negotiations with the IAEA it will have the party's full backing.

"Central Committee has said that we do not want to destabilise the government, but all the responsibility is theirs," said Prakash Karat, General Secretary, CPI(M).

The Politburo had warned the government of serious consequences if it went ahead with negotiations with the International Atomic Energy Agency and Nuclear Suppliers Group.

The Left has also made it clear that the government can go to the coming meeting of the IAEA in Vienna, but cannot talk about the 123 deal.

Also the Left parties plan to hold nationwide agitation from 1-16 September highlighting the adverse consequences on Indo-US nuclear deal and Indo-US strategic alliance.

The Left now is waiting for a decision from the Congress leadership.

However, despite all the dire warnings by the Left, Prime Minister Manmohan Singh stood firm on India going ahead with Indo-US nuclear deal.

In a joint press conference with the visiting Japanese prime minister, Dr Manmohan Singh made it clear that India will go to the Nuclear Suppliers Group, a necessary step for the nuke deal to go through.

"Certainly true that we have some turbulence but I have confidence we shall be able to over come it. When winter comes spring cannot be far behind," said Singh.

But the Left has decided to wait till the government spells out its stand on negotiations with the International Atomic Energy Agency.

Left sources made it clear to NDTV that they would announce their plans on the future of their ties with the UPA only after a clear statement from the government.

Which means all eyes will be on September 18 when the Atomic Energy Commission chief Anil Kakodkar travels to Vienna to attend the IAEA meeting.

Divisions within Left

The 85-member Central Committee of the CPI(M) on Wednesday began a two-day meet in the Capital to discuss the standoff with the government and it is expected to endorse the decision taken by the CPI(M) politburo.

The CPI(M) is making it absolutely clear that India can go to the IAEA meeting, the world atomic body, but it cannot talk about the 123 deal.

In other words, the support to the UPA government would be withdrawn if the government goes ahead and negotiates a safeguards agreement with the IAEA and the Nuclear Suppliers Group.

Meanwhile, it's been decided, the debate on the Indo-US nuclear deal in Parliament will be held on August 29 and 30, first in the Lok Sabha and then Rajya Sabha.

But there seem to be divisions within the Left on the way forward. While a section believes that efforts should be made to resolve the crisis through dialogue, there are others who say the Left has no choice but to withdraw support.

On Monday, veteran communist leader Jyoti Basu had said that pulling down the government was not an option and that the crisis would be resolved through dialogue.

But the same day, another Polit Bureau member, MK Pandhe, had said the Left would not have any other option but to pull out.
Print Story Story Video Story Images Story Comments Message Board
Story Finder 
Save & Share Yahoo Digg Reditt Del Newsvine
 
User Comments [ +Comment on the story ]
NDTV Posted By S.P.Singh-Friday, August 24, 2007
Every decision has two sides.One can always count negative points of every issue. But comparison has to be drawn with respect to given circumstances & needs. India needs energy despirately.Which can only push the country into development zone & subsequently eliminate the negative forces of corruption.Because even education can not proced on without putting development into pace. The integrity & sincerity of Dr. Manmohan Singh is unquestionable.LEFT SHOULD FORGET ABOUT POLITICS & THINK OF NATIONALITY.
 
NDTV Posted By John oommen-Friday, August 24, 2007
The left was against telecom liberalisation, they agitated, burned a few buses and killed a few innocent people, and then kept quiet; they were dead against computerisation, and they burned a few more buses and killed a few more people and then kept quiet. Both these things became means and ways of life for the millions of this country. Now they are against nuclear liberlisation, they would rather have an energy deficient India than a progressing India. give them a few buses to burn and a few unknown names to kill, and they will keep quiet . they might 'confess' to their sins after 20 years.
 
NDTV Posted By ANDREW-Friday, August 24, 2007
Any subservient behaviour by India to China will be welcomed by the Left.Are these left leaders on the payroll or do they get any incentives from the Chinese communist party one wonders. It appears they are like Chinese trojan hourses stationed in INDIA
 
NDTV Posted By harshitbaid-Friday, August 24, 2007
If any future left for leftparty in india then their is no future left for India.THINK ABOUT IT MY DEAR INDIANS.
 
NDTV Posted By AJAY JAGGA-Thursday, August 23, 2007
The Left has put the ball in the court of Congress on Indo-US Nuke deal. Now it is for the Congress to see and do brain storming session to find out the ways to come out of it. The Congress should have taken into confidence, all the constituents of UPA. After all they are running a Government of coalition and cracks are already visible.
 
NDTV Posted By samba-Thursday, August 23, 2007
Any agreement with China will be OK for Left. With any other country they are against anything. India and Indian people whould not grow. This is only aim of Left
 
NDTV Posted By Dr Pritam Singh-Thursday, August 23, 2007
After a long time, I agree completely with the Left in India. This nuke deal is an environmental disaster and future generations will condemn this generation if it is not stopped now. People should rise above their nationalistic sentiments and should view this deal rationally from the viewpoint of its long term harmful consequences
 
NDTV Posted By Paban-Thursday, August 23, 2007
Mr.PM We are with you. You Dared globalisation and the country is reaping the benefits of economic boom now. The country will be ever grateful to you for this. It is expected that you stand form and go ahead with the nuke deal.
 
NDTV Posted By binu-Thursday, August 23, 2007
EVERYONE KNOW THAT THE NUCLEAR DEAL WAS STARTED BY HON.MR.VAJPAYEE AND WHY THEY ARE SILENT ON THIS NOW ?. IF THEY ARE LITTLE INTERESTED IN IMPROVING THE SITUATION OF OUR COUNTRY, THEN THEY SHOULD COME OUT BY OPENLY SUPPORTING GOVT. TO GO AHEAD WITH THIS AGREEMENT THEREBY THEY CAN TEACH A LESSON TO THIS STUPID LEFT WHO CANN'T THINK ABOUT FUTURE.
 
NDTV Posted By Shovon-Thursday, August 23, 2007
Duniya Pagal Hain, Aur Politicians Dewana. That's all folks.
 
NDTV Posted By Noleft Noright-Thursday, August 23, 2007
Left has started feeling it will be truly be LEFT behind and become a 'party of no consequence' if India surges forward. A party whose ideology has relevance in the whole world lives under an ILLUSION. It has till now managed to hold the Nation hostage with just about 5% vote share and is desperate to make some more space with a dubious posturing. It is pur anathema to US and nothing so much in 123 Agreement that is driving the Comrades make so much noise. All this is based on the Comrades' perception that it will be NOW or NEVER for the Communists in India!
 
NDTV Posted By mahesh shirke-Thursday, August 23, 2007
CPI(M)'s...dayz in the Indian politics r numbered!!!!...they should now realy pull the govt down..if they realy hve tht much guts!!!
 
NDTV Posted By sunil-Thursday, August 23, 2007
There are no permanent friends and enemies for nation . India needs this deal to break nuclear apaethied. This may be a step which may open the road forward. This is in the interest of country. Why left has so much fear of american coercion´. Lets reap the benifit now and we will stand later for the adversity if any!!!!!!
 
NDTV Posted By Manoj Jogia-Thursday, August 23, 2007
well we need to know the reason why there is protest from Left & others , let them talk openly let us all know that why should we not go ahead? Advani's statement 2 days back that this government should go why? can he explain?
 
NDTV Posted By Vincent-Thursday, August 23, 2007
Our PM Showed courage to go ahead with 123 deal. All nation with you Mr.PM. GO AHEAD !!!!
 
NDTV Posted By Srini-Thursday, August 23, 2007
i learnt a bid\g lesson during my stay in teh US. You cannot get even 1 dollar for free. That is America. Americans(not all but many) are shrewd businessmen and American politicions will never involve in any charity work of empowring India to become the regional power house. They know that China is well on its course to become regional power and they will never volunteer to make India the second regional power which only goes against their die hard philosophy to be the only super power in the world with only followers around the world. If embarrasment is the take away to retain our soveriegnity and dignity, better be embarassed than become a slave to the americans for ages. God(America) only knows if we can ever comeout out of the slavery if 123 is signed up. I would rather stick with Russia, not on ideological grounds, but to keep a check on America's bid to rule the world, whatever way it may be.
 
NDTV Posted By Santy-Thursday, August 23, 2007
What do you mean by 123 traty ? Ask the members from parliament, i guarantee you that most of them does not know the treaty itself. I want to support Mr.Prime Minister for daring...The country needs power for the power striving country of ours for the development. Let us support.
 
NDTV Posted By Joseph Victor-Thursday, August 23, 2007
Bravo Dr Singh ! You are doing the right thing, by not budging to the stupid reasons of left. There are some questions that the left needs to answer. Can they get an assurance that the deal will not be pursued by any of the coming govts ? As you are aware, Pakistan and china are "desperate" to get a deal like this, so is this that bad a deal ? Polls suggest that your supposed red bastions (WB & Kerala) are against the decision of opposing the govt, so for whom are you playing this drama ? Isnt it just Karat's ego. Are you guys planning to build a hunger struck, jobless, dark India ? It's the 21st century and the cold-war is over if you are not aware of it. Russia has fallen and China is adopting free trade . So wake up and be pragmatic.
 
NDTV Posted By Dr. Sanjukta Ghosh-Thursday, August 23, 2007
If historical events are equivalent to our seasons then possibly many history will be repeated. Are we going ahead with such thoughts?????????????????
 
NDTV Posted By Ramachandra-Thursday, August 23, 2007
Though his stand is commendable, does he have the constitutional sanction? This agreement is by minority in the parliament and his cabinet is a minority cabinet. The technical support with which they were in government is not extended to this agreement. The argument that the international agreements do not need parliamentary approval is untenable as a minority government is not contemplated in the constitution. He is presently enjoying the position similar to what Miss Mayawati is enjoying because of the Ante Defection Law, all in the name of democracy, for the people. JAI MATA DI.
 
NDTV Posted By Kaushal Asrani-Thursday, August 23, 2007
The PM has shown courage in saying that he will go ahead with the deal.In a single move, he has snubbed the Left (he must be pretty fed up of them by now) and stolen BJPs thunder (they would have undoubtedly gone ahead with the deal too had they been in power). Its a win-win situation for the country, as we still go ahead with the deal after which undoubtedly the Govt will collapse and then the Left ( as Surendran below just mentioned)will be permanently confined the dustbins of history
 
NDTV Posted By Kamal-Thursday, August 23, 2007
Hey i am not sure y Left is blamed for this. When they are against it, they say it for some reason, which no one knows it. Y dont we get to know the reason. I find every web site says, LEFT(even BJP is against it) is against the 123 deal but no one has put the reason of why it is. May be if we get the reason, we might even feel LEFT is "right"
 
NDTV Posted By Prikshat Verma-Thursday, August 23, 2007
In the first place.A panel of experts with a representative of each party should have been formed and the deal discussed,before proceeding.Secondly, PM should have been astute to see the catch in this deal before signing it.THIS IS A COMMON SENSE WHEN SIGNING A CONTRACT WITH USA.I know very well what they can put in fine print and language.You have to be sharp to understand that and have to have stayed in US a few years to understand the americans psyche.The whole cabinet of Manmohan Singh made fool of themselves.NOW THE BEST WAY IS TO GO WITH THE DEAL( if,it can not be renegotiated).GET INDIA THE TECH OF NUCLEAR POWER AND WHEN THE TIME COMES TO MAKE NUCLEAR TESTS, DO IT AS IF,USA DOES NOT EXIST. (THATS THE WAY WE CAN BEAT USA THINKING.BY THINKING AND DOING LIKE THEM.) WE HAVE BEEN TAUGHT TOO MUCH MORALITY IN FOREIGN AFFAIRS BY STUPID LEADERS !!!
 
NDTV Posted By cautious-Thursday, August 23, 2007
Left are the only ones Left to stand up for the national cause.People who are crying like babies for Papa Bush and calling LEft as agents of china should be deported to the US!
 
NDTV Posted By Ratnam V V -Wednesday, August 22, 2007
I hope that left woud see the wrting on the wall and atlst refrain from withdrawing support a this cruciak jyncture. Irrespective of the lrft. PM should go agead with IAEA & NSG discussions. The deal will benifit the countrt not only get access to variios technologies and not only nueclar power which will provide the necessary energy security with more environmentally friendly technology compared to the Coal base thermal power. IT SHOULD NOT BE FORGOTTEN THAT IF THIS DEAL DOES NOT GO THROUGH iNDIA WILL NOT BE ABLE TO DEFEND OTHER DEALS AS WELL.
 
NDTV Posted By jinishans-Wednesday, August 22, 2007
India's 30% Thorium resource base can fuel for next 2500 years of Electricity - http://jinishans.blogspot.com/2007/08/indias-30-thorium-resource-base-can.html
 
NDTV Posted By jinishans-Wednesday, August 22, 2007
see my post in my blog - jinishans.blogspot.com or jinishans.blogspot.com/2007/08/indias-30-thorium-resource-base-can.html
 
NDTV Posted By MOHAN-Wednesday, August 22, 2007
The present Left's sharing of power by supporting UPA will be in jeopardy, if they continue do China's bidding on the US-India deal. I hope they are not that fool hardy to dig their own grave. The general informed population will mount campaign against the Left that it will be relgated to the history books with a foot note that Left owed allegiance to its paymasters in China and the nation threw them out into dustbin of history for thier despicable act of compromisng India's national and economic security by using India's inclusive democratic traditions. Media appears to be so impotent that it has failed to call the Left's bluff by showing Left's insiduous actions against India's longterms interests. Wish India wakes up and shows the the Left the door.
 
NDTV Posted By Prikshat Verma-Wednesday, August 22, 2007
YOU POLITICIANS OF INDIA DEAL AS CORRUPT SHREWD PERSONS WITH USA.JUST LIKE AS YOU DEAL IN INDIA WITH INDIANS.AND YOU WILL WIN OVER THEM.AND EVERYTHING WILL BE FINE WITH THIS DEAL.THINK LIKE A CORRUPT INDIAN BUT, TALK IN ENGLISH.
 
NDTV Posted By KRNPrasad-Wednesday, August 22, 2007
This is nothing but Zimmiks that's playing by left parties to maintain command over UPA governenment and Blakmailing the congress party.
 
NDTV Posted By DESI BABU-Wednesday, August 22, 2007
Is there any way to deport these hon'ble CPI & CPM MP to China? If yes, please give them Free Green card to China and one way Air-tickets......
 
NDTV Posted By Surendran Menon-Wednesday, August 22, 2007
Come on you proxies of China - please pull down the Govt. so that we can have fresh elections after which you will be consigned to the dustbin of history
 


About Us | Advertise | Feedback | Disclaimer | Investor | Careers | Transmission | Distribution | Complaint Redressal
© Copyright NDTV Convergence Limited 2009. All rights reserved.