Shows    »   We The People    »  The Indira Gandhi legacy
NDTV
Barkha Dutt It has been 25 years since prime minister Indira Gandhi was assassinated on Oct 31, 1984. Worshipped by her supporters and cursed by her enemies, the Iron Lady, as she was called, paved the way for democracy in India during the twentieth century.

Nationalisation of banks, the green revolution, her foreign policies, India's victory in the war against Pakistan, and the country's surge toward space technologies are all credited to her. Indira's primary strength lay in her ability to connect with the poor. It was Indira Gandhi who first introduced anti-poverty programmes, reaching out to the poorest and most destitute.

But in complete contrast to the above accolades were Indira's controversial decisions. She was often criticized for her autocracy and a rigid approach to policies, crushing rebels along the way. The dark days of the Emergency and Operation Blue Star became the ultimate causes of her downfall. Since then, national and world opinion about Indira Gandhi's legacy stands divided. Was Indira Gandhi India's best prime minister or the most controversial? Join the debate on We the People.
What's your take?
Q.Was Indira Gandhi India's best prime minister ?

Yes

No

Can't say
Recent Debates
Player will load here
National language: What's that?
National language: What's that?
Vande Mataram & Fatwa politics
Vande Mataram & Fatwa politics
The Indira Gandhi legacy
The Indira Gandhi legacy
Is a peace initiative with the Maoists possible?
Is a peace initiative with the Maoists possible?
Is Mumbai no longer cosmopolitan?
Is Mumbai no longer cosmopolitan?
Gandhi's legacy: Are we too politically correct?
Gandhi's legacy: Are we too politically correct?
Women in Army: Time for a greater role?
Women in Army: Time for a greater role?
Should everyone in India know Hindi?
Should everyone in India know Hindi?
Austerity, Congress style?
Austerity, Congress style?
Is politics killing history and literature?
Is politics killing history and literature?
Religious symbols in a secular society
Religious symbols in a secular society
Political parties scared of history?
Political parties scared of history?
Has India over-reacted to the Swine Flu?
Has India over-reacted to the Swine Flu?
Not just skin deep prejudice
Not just skin deep prejudice
Right to Motherhood
Right to Motherhood
Royalty and Indian Politics
Royalty and Indian Politics
The right to be gay
The right to be gay
One nation, one Board: Is India ready?
One nation, one Board: Is India ready?
Royalty in the age of democracy
Royalty in the age of democracy
Women and Affirmative Action
Women and Affirmative Action
Racism: Indians as targets
Racism: Indians as targets
Ragging: From tradition to abuse
Ragging: From tradition to abuse
Will Indian polity get a younger soul?
Will Indian polity get a younger soul?
Who is India's Obama?
Who is India's Obama?
Who's afraid of Mayawati?
Who's afraid of Mayawati?
How safe are our schools and colleges?
How safe are our schools and colleges?
Should godmen stay out of politics?
Should godmen stay out of politics?
Small parties; big ambitions
Small parties; big ambitions
Small parties; big ambitions
Small parties; big ambitions
Politics in the age of TV
Politics in the age of TV
New middle-class political activism
New middle-class political activism
Death, love, life on TV
Death, love, life on TV
Regional parties: The King makers?
Regional parties: The King makers?
Should IPL and elections be held together?
Should IPL and elections be held together?
Jai Ho: From Dharavi to LA and back
Jai Ho: From Dharavi to LA and back
Bhopal's battle with love
Bhopal's battle with love
Girl commits suicide after humiliation
Girl commits suicide after humiliation
Valentine gifts for Pramod Muthalik
Valentine gifts for Pramod Muthalik
RSS disowns Mangalore attackers
RSS disowns Mangalore attackers
Tough message to moral police
Tough message to moral police
The Advertising Debate
The Advertising Debate
Women gear up to fight for themselves
Women gear up to fight for themselves
No one helped me: Mangalore victim
No one helped me: Mangalore victim
Five held for attacking MLA's daughter
Five held for attacking MLA's daughter
New team to probe pub attack
New team to probe pub attack
'Mangalore pub, girls to blame'
'Mangalore pub, girls to blame'
Maharashtra ATS to quiz Ram Sene chief
Maharashtra ATS to quiz Ram Sene chief
Should Satyam be saved?
Should Satyam be saved?
No war, no peace: India`s Pakistan problem?
No war, no peace: India's Pakistan problem?
Best of We the people 2008
Best of We the people 2008
J&K verdict: End of separatism?
J&K verdict: End of separatism?
Has the Minority Affairs Minister embarrassed India`s Muslims?
Has the Minority Affairs Minister embarrassed India's Muslims?
Enough is enough: India`s 9/11
Enough is enough: India's 9/11
Anger into action: What can India do next?
Anger into action: What can India do next?
Is the Indian dream in danger after the global financial crisis?
Is the Indian dream in danger after the global financial crisis?
`Hindu` terror: Myth or fact?
'Hindu' terror: Myth or fact?
Can India`s political establishment create an Obama like inspiration?
Can India's political establishment create an Obama like inspiration?
Obama or McCain: Who is better for India?
Obama or McCain: Who is better for India?
Is India`s city of dreams getting destroyed by regionalism?
Is India's city of dreams getting destroyed by regionalism?
Have the attacks on Christians destroyed India`s image?
Have the attacks on Christians destroyed India's image?
Is it time to decriminalise homosexuality?
Is it time to decriminalise homosexuality?
Why are Indians obsessed with fairness?
Why are Indians obsessed with fairness?
Atif`s laptop, cell yield evidence
Atif's laptop, cell yield evidence
Two churches attacked in Bangalore
Two churches attacked in Bangalore
Delhi blasts: Cops make more arrests
Delhi blasts: Cops make more arrests
Can SIMI and Bajrang Dal be equated?
Can SIMI and Bajrang Dal be equated?
Delhi blasts probe: Cops arrest 3 more suspects
Delhi blasts probe: Cops arrest 3 more suspects
Churches attacked in Karnataka again
Churches attacked in Karnataka again
Delhi blasts: Are police covering up?
Delhi blasts: Are police covering up?
Terror code cracked? Police nab men behind Delhi blasts
Terror code cracked? Police nab men behind Delhi blasts
Atif, key man behind Delhi blasts: Police
Atif, key man behind Delhi blasts: Police
SIMI treasurer taken into custody: Police
SIMI treasurer taken into custody: Police
Delhi blasts: Arrested terrorist confesses
Delhi blasts: Arrested terrorist confesses
Conversions in Karnataka: Myth or reality?
Conversions in Karnataka: Myth or reality?
Is Indian government soft on SIMI?
Is Indian government soft on SIMI?
Mangalore tense after attack on churches
Mangalore tense after attack on churches
SIMI`s Shahbaz sent to police remand,
SIMI's Shahbaz sent to police remand,
SC to hear govt`s plea to extend SIMI ban,
SC to hear govt's plea to extend SIMI ban,
SIMI activist surrenders in Jaipur
SIMI activist surrenders in Jaipur
ADVERTISEMENT
Send us your thoughts
* Name
* Your Comments
* Enter the code shown below
All episodes
 
Surfers Say
Posted by siljishoth on Monday, November 02, 2009
I would like to call ur attention to the condition of india even after 50 years of congress rule. sycophancy, corruption are all hallmarks of congress which was institutionalised by indira. the title of ur show itself is flawed as indira don't have any legacy. This draws me to an article appeared in the HIndu on purchase of news and news papers by powerful candidate using money. there was also a news where it was said that in MP shivraj singh Chauhan allotted plot to journalists and media housed just before assembly elections.Are u people succumb to such pressures and allurings. common man is confused.
Posted by sl.mehra on Monday, November 02, 2009
Before we question the decision of Smt Indira Gandhi regarding imposition of Emergency @ Operation Blue Star, we must ponder at the circumstances leading to those decisions.Yes, her election had been declared null & void by the Allahabad High Court and perhaps the best course of action for her would have been to resign but the opposition instead of taking the fight to the streets should have taken up their cause through institutional means ie fighting out the matter in highest court of the land , rather giving a call to the police and the Army not to obey the Govt authority. Just imagine what would have been the state of the Nation had that call been taken by the Army and the police. Jai prakash Naraian had been a leader all through his life, diametrically opposed to his own ideas from time to time. Had he accepted Pt Nehru's offer to join his cabinet in the fiftees, he could have a Natural Successor to the India's first Prime Minister. These very people who now question her decision of operation Blue Star use to laud her for her bold decision without which, perhaps, the situation in Punjab could have been any thing, to say the least. A democratically elected Govt has a right to handle with a situation in a manner as it deems fit, of course, within the frame-work of the Constitution only and if the same is construed by a large section of the society as being not in the larger interest of the Nation, they have a golden opportunity to throw out that Govt at the hustings. Judging in its entirety, Indira Gandhi was a courageous leader though, at times, suffering from fear phycosis , very unlike her own father.
Posted by Siddharth Trivedi on Monday, November 02, 2009
She was the lady with vision that can make INDIA superpower and free from any terrorist attacks
i born in 1983 and i curse myself that i born in the year when she was killed.
Posted by ABDULAZIZ BASTAVI on Monday, November 02, 2009
IN MY OPINION, THE BIGGEST FAILURE WAS ANNOUNCEMENT OF NATIONALIZATION POLICY DECLARED DURING INDEPENCE DAY SPEECH ON 15 AUGUST (RED FORT).
THIS POLICY HELPED CONGRESS BUT HURT THE NATION.
Posted by SIDDHESH on Monday, November 02, 2009
100% Mrs Gandhi is the best prime minister india has ever seen. today in the era of coaliation politics we miss a sole leadership on whom the mantle of magnum India could be entrusted. a leader that would neither bow to international pressure or internal hiccups. the place which belong to only Mrs Gandhi a place which can neither be matched by her predecessor nor could be reached by her successors till now
oh! mother India ! where are you? WE need you!!!!!!
Posted by Krishna Harida on Sunday, November 01, 2009
Definitely she earned the name of an iron lady; yes she was charismatic and used it to her best especially with the USA and Nixon in particular. But in India her mistakes far outnumbered her achievements; with scant respect to the opposition or for that matter any one who opposed her and the Emergency that was the height when insecurity and mistrust seemed to haunt her and thereby ceated a legacy by itself; of shchophants that still plagues the congress and no one is willing to look beyond the "Gandhi" name so much so the election posters do not even mention about Shastri or for that matter Narasimha Rao, its only Nehru, Indira, Rajiv, Sonia, Rahul and now Priyanka who still prefers to retain the Gandhi name to use it at the right time. Even Sanjay's name sees no mention, parhaps to keep a check on Meneka and Varun.In this overall scenario she cannot definitely be said to the best PM India had. In fact the closest would be Atal Behari Vajpayee, his only stigma was he belonged to the BJP but he definitely kept it in check.
Posted by sourav bose on Sunday, November 01, 2009
she was no doubt a strong lady with strong views though the debate will remain whether it was good or ugly.
Posted by Tenzin on Sunday, November 01, 2009
She was a strong leader but not the best. Historically speaking she was a politician since at the age of 4 and generally it says that politics is a dirty game. So there is no escape route to say that she was always wise.
Posted by Sandeep on Sunday, November 01, 2009
What ever people may say about Mrs India Gandhi, in my view there is no doubt she was a very strong leader and always wanted to make India a super power i dont think we will have a leader such her in coming future.
Posted by Ambreesh, Ghaziabad on Sunday, November 01, 2009
India needed a strong-willed, ruthless and autocratic leader, Indira Gandhi alone foots the bill. The performance of critics of Emergency and their drawing of pension speaks volumes about these politicians.