| |
Newsletter 
  RSS
NDTV.com
Updated: February 09, 2010 23:14 IST
   What's New:   Classifieds   |   Auto   |   Jobs   |   Tutoring US only NDTV GURUJI NDTV Search
NDTV
Vikram Chandra India's poverty was under global spotlight at the Oscars with the blockbuster Slumdog Millionaire, tracing the rags to riches story of a slum boy. The huge success of the film has proved that rags, if packaged and marketed well, may indeed be converted into riches.

All those touchy about the representation of Indian poverty would argue that portrayal of this kind, that often amuses a westerner, would probably make an Indian cringe and feel embarrassed.

The question to ask is, whether criticism over the cinematic representation of the 'other' India stems from the fact that a westerner amplified this brutal reality for audiences abroad ? Is the portrayal of an unchanging reality in direct conflict with the story of a ‘New India’. If yes, do we still have reason to cheer over Slumdog's success?
What's your take?
Q.Should India really be celebrating the Slumdog success?

Yes

No

Can't say
Recent highlights
 
Player will load here
Shiv Sena: Holding Mumbai at ransom?
Shiv Sena: Holding Mumbai at ransom?
60 years of the Indian Republic
60 years of the Indian Republic
Should India and Pakistan start dialogue?
Should India and Pakistan start dialogue?
Security worries creating Islamophobia?
Security worries creating Islamophobia?
Ruchika's case: Is media trial the only way to get justice?
Ruchika's case: Is media trial the only way to get justice?
The Big Fight: Best of 2009
The Big Fight: Best of 2009
Copenhagen: What next?
Copenhagen: What next?
The Telangana row
The Telangana row
The problem of price rise
The problem of price rise
How do we deal with Naxalism?
How do we deal with Naxalism?
The language debate
The language debate
Should the Dalai Lama visit Tawang?
Should the Dalai Lama visit Tawang?
Communal riots in the age of TV media
Communal riots in the age of TV media
Climate change: What should India do?
Climate change: What should India do?
Should labour laws be changed?
Should labour laws be changed?
Should India worry about China?
Should India worry about China?
Are Naxalites terrorists or bandits?
Are Naxalites terrorists or bandits?
Austerity drive going overboard?
Austerity drive going overboard?
Behind encounter killings
Behind encounter killings
UPA II's report card: Is the govt performing?
UPA II's report card: Is the govt performing?
An undivided India?
An undivided India?
BJP: The crisis within
BJP: The crisis within
Big Fight special: Indo-Pak relations
Big Fight special: Indo-Pak relations
'Monumental' Maya
'Monumental' Maya
The 'reality' debate
The 'reality' debate
Lessons learnt?
Lessons learnt?
India-Pak: To talk or not to talk?
India-Pak: To talk or not to talk?
Gay activists vs religious leaders
Gay activists vs religious leaders
The Big Bang Budget
The Big Bang Budget
Media activism and justice
Media activism and justice
Women's Reservation Bill: A reality?
Women's Reservation Bill: A reality?
BJP: Which way forward?
BJP: Which way forward?
Is the Indian diaspora dream over?
Is the Indian diaspora dream over?
Obama's AfPak policy
Obama's AfPak policy
First time MPs: Agents of Change?
First time MPs: Agents of Change?
Election '09: The big surprises
Election '09: The big surprises
Where will the Muslim vote go?
Where will the Muslim vote go?
The LTTE factor in Tamil Nadu
The LTTE factor in Tamil Nadu
The Big Fight in Bihar
The Big Fight in Bihar
Where are the 'real' issues?
Where are the 'real' issues?
Crime vs politics?
Crime vs politics?
Will the politics of hate work?
Will the politics of hate work?
The Big Fight: Young politicians
The Big Fight: Young politicians
The Big Fight: Election Battleground
The Big Fight: Election Battleground
The Big Fight: The Slumdog Reality
The Big Fight: The Slumdog Reality
Is the railway miracle for real? Join the debate
Is the railway miracle for real? Join the debate
The Big Fight: SP-Cong dispute
The Big Fight: SP-Cong dispute
Can mob hooliganism ever be justified?
Can mob hooliganism ever be justified?
What will President Obama mean for India?
What will President Obama mean for India?
Satyam: How deep does the rot go?
Satyam: How deep does the rot go?
The best of Big Fight 2008
The best of Big Fight 2008
How can we fix the political system?
How can we fix the political system?
The big fight against terror
The big fight against terror
Which metro in India has the worst roads?
Which metro in India has the worst roads?
Malegaon investigation: What does it mean?
Malegaon investigation: What does it mean?
Will the Obama victory change the world?
Will the Obama victory change the world?
Why is migrant labour being targetted?
Why is migrant labour being targetted?
Should you worry about housing prices?
Should you worry about housing prices?
Market meltdown: What next?
Market meltdown: What next?
How can violence in Orissa be controlled?
How can violence in Orissa be controlled?
Nanavati panel: Justice served or denied?
Nanavati panel: Justice served or denied?
Is the financial crisis over?
Is the financial crisis over?
India: Winner all the way?
India: Winner all the way?
Should homosexuality be legalised?
Should homosexuality be legalised?
Will Tata say `Tata`?
Will Tata say 'Tata'?
J&K: The crisis deepens
J&K: The crisis deepens
Starting a peace dialogue
Starting a peace dialogue
The new face of terror
The new face of terror
Nuclear deal: Who wins, who loses?
Nuclear deal: Who wins, who loses?
All Episodes
ADVERTISEMENT
Send us your thoughts
Name *
 
E-mail *
 
City *
 
Your Comments *
 
Enter the code shown below *
In the news
Slumdog mirrors the reality: Irrfan Khan
Subhash K Jha
Friday, February 27, 2009
Oscar-nominated film Slumdog Millionaire has been criticised for selling Mumbai's misery to the West,
NDTV What's wrong with Slumdog? says Shah Rukh
NDTV Danny Boyle to work for Mumbai slum kids
NDTV Shilpa Shetty criticises Slumdog
NDTV Slumdog kids back in shanties
 

Ananda , Bangalore :

While it makes sense to celebrate the individual success of Rahman and Resul, and the exposure that Indian cinema is getting, we should remember the film is a british film and doesnt portray a great image of India...so India cannot really cheer over the success of the film
2/28/2009 4:25:21 PM

anand , chennai :

its really a great achievement by indians,its a great view to look at that side who does't know about 'suffering people' in slums
2/28/2009 4:23:06 PM

mohan john stephenson , kollam,kerala :

WHY ARE WE SO GUILTY ABOUT THE SLUMS?WHY DID'NT SOMEBODY DO SOMETHING ABOUT OUR SLUMS?IN THE MOVIE,FOR THE FIRST TIME THE REAL FACE OF INDIA,THE FACE THAT WE REFUSE TO LOOK AT WAS SHOWN TO US MORE THAN THE OUTSIDERS.THIS IS THE TRUTH,THE REAL UGLY SIDE OF MY COUNTRY,AND I AM NOT ASHAMED OF IT.I AM ONLY ASHAMED THAT I AM NOT ABLE TO DO ANYTHING TO WIPE THIS STARK REALITY AWAY,TO GET RID OF THIS HURTFUL UGLY FACE OF THE REAL INDIA.WE ARE GUILTY THAT'S WHY THE RUSH TO FIND AN EXCUSE TO BLAME ANYBODY THAT WAS HONEST ENOUGH TO SHOW ME THE TRUE FACE.LET'S WAKE UP FROM OUR SLUMBER AND CORRECT THE MISTAKES THAT WE ARE NOT INTERESTED IN CORRECTING.
2/28/2009 4:07:49 PM

Suresh Subramanian , MILTON KEYNES, UK :

This is one of the first and the best opportunity to India to prove the world that India is rising.....apparently from the Slum to conquer the World, in every aspect. Sometimes you need a western media or Director to take this to the World. Well done the entire Team of Slumdog Millionaire.
2/28/2009 3:50:09 PM

Lal Singh , Abu Dhabi :

The movie amplifies the poverty facts and uses bad words. This is not what India stands for. It was not directed by an India director. Its not an Indian brain. Why celebrate it.
2/28/2009 3:25:06 PM

Pal , UK :

I think there is nothing to be embarassed about a slum being shown which really exists in our country. What we should be embarassed about is that it is still there. Why don't we debate about what can be done to hasten the redevelopment of the slum. The people living in the slums are only aware of their rights it seems and not about their duty to follow the government's plans, if it is benefitting them and give a helping hand in building the city. In every city of the world, people travel a long distance to reach their work-place, that is no reason for not to move out.
2/28/2009 3:11:21 PM

Raj Shekhar , Visakhapatnam :

First of all , according to my view there is nothing that India should be proud enough for the Oscars received by the movie "Slumdog Millionare", as it was directed by an Hollywood Director....The only thing that we Indians can be proud of is the Oscar received by Mr.A.R.Rehman. And regarding the slums, its the truth that we have to face, its just that the movie has shown it to the whole world which is not being digested by our people. Thats all....
2/28/2009 3:10:01 PM

TANMOY SABUD , Lagos, Nigeria :

A Slum dog millionaire is an honest & genuine portray of Indian poverty which is harsh to digest as an Indian. The accolade would not have been made if the film is made by any Indian director or producer. Warner brothers production is eyeing for huge untapped Indian market. This is the initiation of that journey. You will see Indian movies will get Oscar for coming 5-6 years just like beauty contest won by Sushmita & Awishraiya in past.
2/28/2009 3:08:25 PM

Mohammad Nawaz , Kuwait :

We have reasons to cheer Slumdog Millionnaire for its sheer cinematic excellence and for top quality contribution Indian artists/technicians have provided as partners. To suspect all the time that Westerners choose poverty to mock is silly. Rather than criticising the film, it will be better to us understand and find solutions to this problem. Can there be a time bound solution for this? Let us find this answer.
2/28/2009 2:39:42 PM

NAVEEN PRAKASH , Haridwar :

Movies always portrays things in magnified manner, but it's also true that reality bites. I just hope our leaders watch this movie and contemplate that it's a reflection on them.
2/28/2009 2:26:14 PM
  1   2   3   4   5   6   7   8