Mulayam Singh Yadav, who provides crucial external support to the UPA government, has told the Lok Sabha that he is opposed to Foreign Direct Investment in multi-brand retail as it will hurt the interests of Indian farmers. He was participating in a discussion on the government's major reform policy; the debate will be followed by a vote tomorrow and the government's floor managers are counting on Mr Yadav not to vote against it; they reckon he could abstain or walk out.
In his speech, Mr Yadav appealed to Congress president Sonia Gandhi, "There is Gandhi in your name...remember what he said...you are forgetting Swadeshi
and getting in Videshi
". He also took on the government's first speaker Kapil Sibal for saying that FDI would be introduced only in 53 cities that had a population over 10 lakhs. "If you are convinced that this policy will help the people, why introduce it only towns with population over 10 lakhs? It is because these big global supermarkets do not want to go to smaller towns where they won't be able to earn as much," Mr Yadav said to thumping from anti-FDI sections in the Lok Sabha.
The BJP's Sushma Swaraj led that brigade today; the Leader of Opposition initiated the debate, slamming the government for what she said was a policy that would hurt small retailers and for not building political consensus despite promising to take along all parties on the major reform. (Read: FDI in retail is death knell for small industries, says Sushma Swaraj)
She said, "farmers are forced to throw their potatoes away while McDonald's imports the potatoes it uses," and ended her fiery argument, replete with political jibes at the Congress and its top leadership, by saying, "we don't want to win by defeating you, we want to win by convincing you."
Mr Sibal, who is a senior minister at the Centre countered Mr Swaraj's accusations point by point, saying FDI would be introduced only in 18 states and state governments could choose whether or not to implement it. Accusing the opposition of exaggerating the evils of FDI, he said it had no right to force its opposition on chief ministers who wanted to implement FDI in retail. (Read: FDI in retail in favour of farmers, says Kapil Sibal)
Both speakers accused the other's party of changing their stand. While Ms Swaraj asked why "the PM's viewpoint on FDI had changed," Mr Sibal said, "In 2004, the BJP said in its vision document that it supported FDI in retail...Now that you are not in power, you have changed your stance."
Interrupted by angry interjections, they set the tone for a heated debate, one that has already seen Saugata Roy of the Trinamool Congress warn that big retailers, "will come as traders and end up as kings," as allusion to British rule in India.
As Ms Swaraj ended her speech she turned to the BSP
and Samajwadi Party benches in the Lok Sabha and made a direct appeal
saying, "If the government does not take the decision back, then I
appeal to my colleagues here, vote with us and defeat FDI. The
government will not fall if they lose the vote."
which has managed to convince all UPA partners, including the DMK, to
stand by it in tomorrow's vote, has been kept guessing by the SP and
BSP, which provide external support to it, on which way they will vote.
Ms Swaraj was alluding to the fact that these parties, especially the
SP, have spoken against FDI in retail outside Parliament, but have
hinted that they might bail out the government to keep the BJP at bay.
But while SP chief Mulayam Singh Yadav was non-committal yesterday, his
brother and party colleague Ram Gopal Yadav said before the debate
today, "The Samajwadi Party is of the opinion that FDI is completely
against the welfare of small traders", adding, "Voting with the BJP may
not be a consideration. The Left is also against FDI but both parties'
policies are poles apart." The government is said to be counting on the
SP to abstain or walk out, either way not voting against it.
BSP, too, has played hard to get, with party chief Mayawati indicating
that her vote on FDI is linked to the passing of a bill that provides
reservation for scheduled castes and tribes in promotions for government
jobs. The BSP reportedly wanted the quota bill to be passed first, and
the government had duly listed it in the Rajya Sabha today. Only, the
SP, which is opposed to the quota bill, did not let the Upper House
function. The Rajya Sabha has been adjourned for the day. As it grapples
with that knot, the Manmohan Singh government wore its confident face
this morning with Parliamentary Affairs Minister Kamal Nath saying, "The
government is confident that the BJP's motion against FDI will be
rejected in both Houses of Parliament." (Watch)
BSP could abstain or, if satisfied with the government's intention on
the quota Bill, even vote in favour of it, the government's floor
managers reckon. She said yesterday that keeping "communal forces" at
bay was a priority, indicating that she would not vote on the same side
as the BJP. "Without seeing the results, we cannot currently support the
policy to introduce FDI in retail. We will decide about voting on the
floor of the House as we don't want to stand by communal parties," Ms
If the BSP and SP both abstain in the 545-seat
Lok Sabha, the majority mark will come down from 273 to 251. The
Congress and its UPA allies have 261 MPs. Anti-FDI MPs add up to 219.
The motion will be put to vote in the Lok Sabha tomorrow. The Rajya
Sabha will begin debating the issue on Thursday and will vote on Friday.
the Rajya Sabha, the government is in a distinct minority and will need
more active support from the SP and the BSP. The Upper House has a
strength of 244. Along with its allies, the UPA has a strength of 94
members. The 10 nominated members may go ahead to vote with the
government. Among the seven Independents, three or four may support the
government. Still, the ruling coalition may have to persuade outside
supporters BSP (15) and SP (9) to vote with the government. The
government is said to be talking to smaller groups too in the Rajya
Sabha to make up numbers.
The government has managed to
consolidate the support of its UPA allies, including the DMK, ahead of
the FDI vote, but some Congressmen from the Telangana region in Andhra
Pradesh have chosen to send ominous signals hours before the crucial
debate begins in the Lok Sabha. Nine Telangana MPs, including minister
Jaipal Reddy, boycotted a meeting with Mr Kamal Nath this morning. The
MPs have not made it clear yet if they plan to abstain during the vote;
sources said they are upset that the Telangana issue is being
overlooked. If they do abstain, they will be defying a Congress whip for
all members to be present during the debate and vote. (Read: Nine Telangana MPs skip meeting with Kamal Nath)
entire BJP-led NDA has closed ranks in opposing the FDI decision. "We
will strongly oppose FDI in both houses. In Lok Sabha, the debate will
be initiated by Sushma Swaraj and our senior leader MM Joshi will
intervene. In Rajya Sabha, the debate will be initiated by Arun Jaitley
and Mr Venkaiah Naidu will intervene," BJP spokesperson Ravi Shankar
Prasad said after the party's parliamentary party meet today.
Left parties, AIADMK, Biju Janata Dal (BJD), Asom Gana Parishad (AGP)
and some other parties have also made their intent to vote against the
government clear. Despite that, the Prime Minister reached out to the
AIADMK yesterday and asked it to reconsider its opposition to the policy
in national interest. The AIADMK rules Tamil Nadu with its chief J
Jayalalithaa as Chief Minister.
The vote in both Houses is a
symbolic one, but a loss could adrenalise the Opposition's demand for a
rollback of the reform, and severely undermine the authority of the
Prime Minister whose government shrank to a minority in September when
key ally Mamata Banerjee and her Trinamool Congress exited the ruling
coalition over the decision to allow 51% Foreign Direct Investment or
FDI in retail. Other reforms opposed by the party included a decision to
limit the supply of subsidised cooking gas to households.